Background and Objectives: At diagnosis, the initial staging of well-differentiated neuroendocrine tumors (WD NETs) aids in treatment planning. The somatostatin receptor (SSTR)-PET has been recommended for staging of WD NETs although limited data are available on its impact on non-gastroeneteropancreatic (GEP) NETs. The main purpose of this study was to compare the stage migration after the addition of SSTR-PET to the workup of patients at the initial staging of GEP NETs to those with non-GEP NETs, and its potential impact on patient management. Methods: This prospective study included patients with WD NETs at initial staging. Demographic data, results of conventional and SSTR-PET staging, and SUVmax were recorded. Three panels of experts assessed the potential impact of SSTR-PET to management. Results: There were 482 patients, including 376 with gastroenteropancreatic (GEP) NETs and 106 non-GEP NETs with a median SUVmax of 34.7 [Q1, Q3: 22.8, 59.1]) and 19.0 [Q1, Q3: 7.9, 39.8]), respectively; p < 0.001. The discordant M-stage was recorded in 111/473 patients (23.5%). PET suggested a higher stage in 78/369 GEP NETs (21.1%), including the detection of extrahepatic metastatic disease in 42/114 (36.8%) patients with liver metastases only on CI. For non-GEP NETs, PET suggested a higher stage in 10/104 (9.6%) and CI suggested a higher stage in 15/104 (14.4%), with CI detecting liver metastases more frequently. The potential impact to management for patients with discordant M-stage was scored as moderate to high between 57/101 (56.4%) and 79/101 (78.2%) of patients. Conclusions: One in five patients are upstaged following SSTR-PET, more frequently with GEP NETs than others. SSTR-PET identifies extrahepatic metastatic disease in >1/3 of patients with presumed liver-only metastases on CI. Stage migration following SSTR-PET may result in frequent moderate or significant management change.