Background: Those working in psychiatric units care for some of the most vulnerable and needy patients within health services, and suffer some of the highest levels of job dissatisfaction and burnout within healthcare workforce. Poor staff morale is bad for patient care and is economically wasteful. The same level of evidence of effectiveness and efficiency should be considered in workforce planning as is required in patient care. This has hitherto not occurred. Aim: To examine the impact and cost effectiveness of strategies to improve staff morale and reduce “burnout” amongst staff working in psychiatric units. Methods: We conducted a systematic review of robust evaluations of strategies designed to improve psychological wellbeing or the working experience of staff working in psychiatric units. We searched the following databases: EMBASE; MEDLINE; PsycINFO; CINAHL; Sociological Abstracts; HMIC; Management and Marketing Abstracts; Management Contents and Inside Conferences (all to 2004), and sought the following outcomes: Psychological wellbeing; Job satisfaction; staff burnout and stress; staff sickness and turnover; Direct and indirect costs. The following designs were included: Randomised Controlled Trails (RCTs); Controlled Clinical Trials (CCTs); Controlled Before and after studies (CBAs); and interrupted time series (ITSs). We conducted a narrative overview of key design features, endpoints and results. Results: We identified eight evaluations of strategies to improve staff morale (3 RCTs; 3 CCTs and 2 CBAs). Educational interventions designed to enhance the skill and competency of staff were the most commonly evaluated, and showed positive impact on at least one outcome of interest. Psycho-social interventions that sought out members of staff who were experiencing emotional problems and offered work-based support and enhanced social support networks were positive in US healthcare settings, but had been incompletely implemented and evaluated in UK settings. Organisational interventions, such as a shift to continuous care and primary nursing also showed a potential to be effective in reducing sickness rates and improving job satisfaction. Conclusions: There is substantial opportunity to design and implement interventions to improve the working experience of staff in psychiatric units. There is an onus to evaluate the longer term impact and cost effectiveness of these strategies. Unfortunately strategies are currently being implemented in the absence of any prospective evaluation. Declaration of interest: The authors have no conflict of interest.
This article reports the development and psychometric properties of two short forms of the 28-item Agnew Relationship Measure, the ARM-12 and ARM-5. For the ARM-12, results of previous research were used together with conceptual considerations to select three items to represent each of four ARM subscales: Bond, Partnership, Confidence, and Openness. For the ARM-5, item-analytic principles were used to select five items to represent overall alliance. In all three ARMs, client and therapist versions were constructed to contain parallel items. We drew data to assess reliability and validity from three UK trials of brief therapy for depression. Results indicated that the two short ARMs have acceptable psychometric properties and that they converged with each other and with the full ARM.
14 November 2012 in Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing
Debates on the absence of women in senior organizational roles continue to proliferate but relatively little attention is paid to the Higher Education (HE) context in which women in leadership roles are seriously under-represented. However, higher education is now central to UK political discourse given the growing controversy around student fees, vice chancellors’ remuneration’ and Brexit. This paper draws on a collaborative research study on the experiences of 105 senior women leaders across 3 UK Universities, which elicited accounts of constraints, successes and career highlights. Our research findings present empirical insights that expose the continuing gender inequalities most notable in senior Higher Education roles. Women’s accounts include stories of diverse experiences, on-going discriminatory practices and a failure to recognise the embedded gendered inequalities that continue to prevail in these institutions. Through a critical interrogation of the narratives of female professors and building on insights from a seminal paper by Broadbridge and Simpson a conceptual framework is offered as a heuristic device to capture critical and reflexive data in future studies of equality and inequality in leadership roles.
In this paper we argue that in the current global healthcare climate, practitioners’ ability to provide compassionate and high quality care is undermined on a daily basis, not least by the organisational priorities of cost containment, of science and technology and, paradoxically, innovations experienced as demands such as specialisation. It is not surprising that the financial and workforce constraints of the global healthcare system, now more than ever, affect the practitioners’ capacity to deliver the optimum level of care, care that is positively influenced by patient satisfaction, a current indicator of quality. Whilst the notions of quality and standards have increasingly become the concern of healthcare organizations, quality cannot be considered in isolation from the healthcare management and occupational health of the workforce. In this paper we argue that healthcare practitioners are especially vulnerable to stress because the very nature of caring as a profession demands high levels of emotional engagement and compromise. It is clear that at a time when healthcare systems are under-resourced and over-stretched, practitioners may experience additional stress, ironically at a time when services need to increase retention, recruitment and job satisfaction. We propose a conceptual framework of stress and compromise in relation to caring and a methodology for developing an intervention that would consider how compromise itself may be utilised and adapted to both alleviate stress and inform individual and professional development.