Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune disease characterized by circulating autoantibodies that deposit in target organs (e.g., kidneys), resulting in chronic inflammation and eventual destruction of the organ. SLE is much more prevalent in females than males in both humans and spontaneous mouse models of lupus, such as NZBxNZW F1 (BWF1) mice. Depleting androgens by castration dramatically increases the susceptibility of BWF1 male to lupus. We compared fecal metabolite profiles of castrated BWF1 (androgen-depleted) male, intact (androgen-replete) male, and female mice. Four analytical platforms were employed to study the profiles of polar metabolites in mouse feces collected from adult BWF1 mice, and a total of 435 metabolites was identified. Of these, the abundance levels of 72 metabolites were significantly different between castrated and intact male groups, and 63 metabolites were different between female and male groups. Pathway analysis indicated that the pathway differences between castrated and intact male mice closely resembled the pathway differences between female and intact male mice, suggesting that low levels of androgens, whether due to depletion (castrated male) or endogenous (female), are associated with multiple fecal metabolomic alterations, which could potentially affect SLE progression. Our findings demonstrate that analyzing fecal metabolites using multiple analytical platforms holds great promise for detecting metabolomic alterations in complex disease model systems.
Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is more prevalent in female mice and humans and is associated with microbiota dysbiosis. We analyzed the fecal microbiota composition in female and male NZBxNZWF1 (BWF1) mice, a model of SLE, using 16S RNA gene sequencing. Composition of gut microbiota differed between adult disease-prone female (pre-disease) and disease-resistant male mice. Transfer of male cecal contents by gavage into female mice suppressed kidney disease (decreased proteinuria) and improved survival. After our mouse colony was moved to a new barrier facility with similar housing, male cecal transplants failed to suppress disease in female recipients. After two years, the protective phenotype reemerged: male cecal transplants once again suppressed disease in female mice. We compared the gut microbiota composition in female and male BWF1 mice for the three different periods, during which the male microbiota either protected or failed to protect female recipients. In female vs. male mice and in female mice receiving male cecal transplants, we found Bacteroides was high, Clostridium was low (high Bacteroides/Clostridium ratio), and Alistipes was present during periods when male cecal transplants suppressed disease. These data suggest that specific bacterial populations may have opposing effects on disease suppression in a model of microbiota transplantation.
The gut microbiota affects autoimmune diseases including lupus. We found that female and male microbiota in NZBxNZWF1 (BWF1) mice differ. Our goal is to understand the relationship between sex, microbiota and disease. Microbiota depletion in females has no impact on disease and female microbiota does not induce disease in males; male microbiota can protect female mice from disease while castrated male microbiota loses this ability (castration induces disease and alters the microbiota in males). Intestinal lamina propria stromal cells (LPSC) can affect microbiota and immunoregulation [via regulating CD103 dendritic cell (CD103DC) development and consequently, peripheral regulatory T cells (pTregs)]. CD103DC function and pTregs are both decreased in female and castrated male mice. Endogenous androgens directly induce genes, RALDH1 and 2 (i.e., retinoic acid production), TGFB and GM-CSF, in LPSC that are critical for CD103 development. Transferred male gut microbiota induce expression of the same genes in LPSC in female recipients that we determined was not due to androgens produced by the male microbiota, since no androgen response genes, ANGTL and CHRD, were induced in highly androgen-sensitive LPSC. The male microbiota metabolomic profile differs from either female or castrated male mice, and includes the RXR agonist metabolite(s), phytol/phytanic acid, that directly induce(s) LPSC to express RALDH1 and 2, TGFB and GM-CSF. We propose that 1) endogenous androgens regulate CD103DC function and microbiota function through the LPSC in males; (2) male-modified microbiota produces metabolite(s) that may mediate protection in female recipients through the LPSC and subsequent restoration of CD103DC function and pTregs. Funded by a TIL grant from the Alliance for Lupus Research and the NIH (R01AR067188)