Spontaneous polarization of a nonpolar molecule upon photoexcitation (the sudden polarization effect) earlier discussed for 90°-twisted alkenes, is observed and calculated for planar ring-fluorinated stilbenes, trans-2,3,5,6,2,3,5,6-octofluorostilbene (tF2356) and trans-2,3,4,5,6,2,3,4,5,6-decafluorostilbene (tF23456). Due to the fluorination, Franck-Condon states and are dominated by the quasi-degenerate HOMO-1→LUMO and HOMO-2→LUMO excitations, while their interaction gives rise to a symmetry-broken zwitterionic S1 state. After optical excitation of tF2356, one observes an ultrafast (~0.06 ps) evolution, that reflects relaxation from initial nonpolar to long-lived (1.3 ns in n-hexane and 3.4 ns in acetonitrile) polar S1. The polarity of S1 is evidenced by a solvatochromic shift of its fluorescence band. The experimental results provide a sensitive test for quantum-chemical calculations. In particular, our calculations agree with the experiment, and raise concerns about the applicability of the common TDDFT approach to relatively simple stilbenic systems.