This study illustrates how two secondary mathematics teachers used students’ incorrect answers as they supported students’ engagement in collective argumentation. Three ways of supporting argumentation when students contributed incorrect answers are exemplified, and the structures of these arguments are investigated. Then, by focusing on the correctness of argument components as represented by the diagrams, we developed a potential model of levels of validity in classroom-based argumentation. The model may help the field to identify fine-grained conditions of validity within episodes of collective argumentation. The findings of this study provide insight into how teachers can manage or capitalize on incorrect parts of an argument when they attempt to support classroom-based argumentation as part of a long-term teaching intervention.
6 March 2025 in Journal of Formative Design in Learning
The integration of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly recognized for its potential to enhance mathematical learning and teaching. Although existing research on student perceptions of using ChatGPT in mathematical learning indicates a high intention to adopt the tool, little is known about how these perceptions influence students’ actual use of it in undergraduate-level mathematics. In this research project, students participated in a semester-long study that included six lab assignments designed to provide a formative learning experience, where they used ChatGPT to deepen their understanding of calculus concepts. This case study used a qualitative approach, following two participants among 12 students who had contrasting perceptions of ChatGPT’s role in mathematical learning. By conducting in-depth analyses of surveys, lab assignments, and chat histories, the study aimed to gain a deeper understanding of how these students applied ChatGPT to support their calculus learning. The results showed that students’ perceptions strongly impact their use of ChatGPT for learning. The learner with positive perceptions of ChatGPT engaged more frequently with the tool (actual usage), demonstrated a greater tolerance for ChatGPT’s mathematics errors (learner satisfaction), and showed greater motivation for its further uses (learning motivation). This usage pattern remained consistent despite the interventions implemented throughout the semester. The study concludes with formative pedagogical implications for integrating ChatGPT into mathematics education. Implications for mathematics teaching and directions for future research were discussed.
1 September 2025 in EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education
This study investigated pre-service mathematics teachers’ (PSMTs’) perceptions of using generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) tools–specifically ChatGPT 4.0 and Student GPT–to support the development of teacher questioning strategies within a mathematics methods course. We examined four key areas: perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, self-efficacy, and behavioral intention, while tracking changes in perceptions over a semester. Data sources included two written reflections, two surveys, and a final interview. Findings indicated that with increased familiarity and improved prompt-writing proficiency, PSMTs developed more positive views of GenAI integration. Perceptions were influenced by factors such as prompt writing skills, prior teaching experience, and training needs. The results highlighted the importance of sustained engagement with GenAI tools and the critical role of mathematics teacher educators in offering structured guidance and formative feedback. The practical implications for designing effective AI-integrated instructional activities were discussed.
19 October 2025 in International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education
Responding to national calls to integrate generative AI into mathematics teacher education, this study developed Student ChatGPT, a custom chatbot designed as an interactive role-playing simulation for preservice secondary mathematics teachers (PSMTs). Specifically, Student GPT simulated a middle school student with misconceptions in ratio reasoning, providing opportunities for PSMTs for practice-based teaching experience. Through qualitative analysis of interactions between PSMTs and Student ChatGPT, an analytic framework was developed focusing on three domains: affective, communicative, and technical, to assess the behavior, strengths, and weaknesses of Student GPT. The results showed that the Student GPT demonstrates strengths in positive expression, clarity, relevance, error types, knowledge, and consistency. These advantages suggest that Student GPT can serve as a practice-based training tool to help PSMTs deepen their pedagogical content knowledge for teaching. However, limitations were noted in negative expression, language, acquisition, and role confusion. Despite these limitations, this study proposed that Student GPT is a valuable tool offering PSMTs low-risk, personalized, and interactive teaching experiences resembling real teacher-student interactions. Implications for mathematics teaching and directions for future research were discussed.
Generative AI makes it easy for students to obtain problem-solving solutions in mathematics, but it also raises the risk of uncritical acceptance. This critical case study develops and examines a rational questioning approach, grounded in Habermas’s (1998) theory of rational behavior, to scaffold students’ validation of AI-generated solutions in a college calculus course. Twelve STEM undergraduates engaged in AI validation activities across one semester. Data included ChatGPT chat histories and written lab justifications from an early lab (pre-rational questioning) and a later lab (post-rational questioning). A microanalysis focused on three aspects: (a) the rationality criteria students applied, (b) the follow-up questions they posed to the AI, and (c) the presence of explicit warrants in their justifications. Findings showed a shift from step-checking to criterion-guided validation guided by rationality components. Students not only attended to content and method correctness but also considered method efficiency and articulated warrants. Students also posed criterion-aligned follow-up questions that fostered rational discourse with the AI, and their written justifications more often included explicitly mathematically grounded warrants. The findings suggest that the rational questioning approach may support students’ validation across three analytic aspects while also highlighting the need for further refinement, particularly with respect to communicative rationality. Implications for instruction and directions for future research are discussed, and potential risks of using AI in mathematics teaching are highlighted.