Digital technologies largely contribute to development and wealth in modern society and play an important role in re-thinking the concept of creativity. Many studies show that both online and offline behaviors impact the growth and well-being of young people. In this study we explored the association between creativity and well-being in young people, focusing on two different areas: creative self and digital creativity, the latter intended as a self-reported creative behavior in the digital field. Results show that, even though both creative and digital self help young people achieve eudaimonic well-being, only creative self reduces depressive symptoms, whilst digital creativity seems to even increase the dimensions of stress and anxiety. This difference provides interesting suggestions for two areas of research: the study of creativity as a response to development and the study of the effects of the use of new technologies on the well-being of young people.