Background: The success of forensic genetics has led to considerable numbers of DNA samples that must be stored. For example, the genetic casework unit of the forensic institute of the French gendarmerie analyzes more than 70,000 casework samples per year mainly from swabs that are fully consumed during DNA extraction. The only way to process further analyses is to preserve DNA. Currently, the most common technique used for the long-term preservation of DNA is to freeze the extracted DNA at −20 °C or −80 °C. However, this preservation method involves significant constraints (large equipment), risks (equipment failure), and is not ecologically sustainable due to its high energy consumption. Many solutions for DNA preservation at room temperature exist based either on fibrous supports or on anhydrobiosis. However, few studies have examined the efficiency of these systems in preserving very-low DNA amounts, such as those in forensic samples (≤1 ng), while ensuring full recovery and the ability to retest the samples many years later. Methods: We choose to evaluate the ability of the anhydrobiosis technology from GenTegra^® LLC to preserve DNA extracts from one month to one accelerated year from different DNA quantities (from 1 ng to 0.2 ng) and sources (NIST, mocked samples, and true casework mixtures). We studied the quantity, integrity of DNA, and also the quality of the STR genetic profiles obtained. Results and Conclusions: Our results prove the high potential of this technology to preserve and to allow an effective recovery of the DNA extracts for forensic purposes.