Given the anticipated shift in the allocation of resources under the common agricultural policy (CAP) toward increasing positive environmental outcomes, this study explores farmer attitudes toward the current principle of connecting direct payments to environmental conditionality, known as cross compliance. Furthermore, we explore whether there have been changes in farmer attitudes toward cross compliance over time by posing identical questions to farmers in both 2010 and 2018. A supplementary survey was designed and administered in conjunction with the core EU Farm Accountancy Data Network (FADN) to assess farmers’ attitudes to linking CAP payments to environmental conditionality. The findings of a generalized ordered logit model indicate a high level of support among farmers for linking direct payments to good agricultural practices and cross compliance standards. Factors influencing farmers’ acceptance of cross compliance can be categorized into several domains, including farm and farmer characteristics, social and institutional attributes, and economic factors. Notably, the level of subsidy dependency emerges as a highly significant factor, with farmers who rely more heavily on direct payments being more inclined to disagree with cross compliance requirements.
Diffuse pollution from agriculture continues to pose a significant threat to waterbodies. This study investigates the role of diverse farming objectives on a farmers’ openness to adopt a suite of mitigative measures that could have a positive effect on water quality. Based on a farmer survey, factor analysis was used to reduce a long list of potential farming objectives to three: long-term economic objectives (LTE), short-term economic objectives (STE) and environmental objectives (ENV). The results of a multivariate ordered probit model indicate that farming objectives are a highly significant predictor of openness to adopt. Our findings suggest that farmers with LTE and ENV objectives are more open to adopting many of the same mitigation measures while farmers with STE objectives are less open.
This paper explores stakeholder responses to policy changes under Ireland's Fifth Nitrates Action Programme (NAP), focusing on the effectiveness of a top-down, compliance-driven approach. Despite the Water Framework and the Nitrates Directives, overall biological status in Irish waterbodies has shown little improvement. Using semi-structured interviews with 16 key informants and responses to open-ended questions from surveys with 42 dairy farmers, responses to qualitative questions, the study analyzes perceptions of new measures and the broader social and ecological challenges influencing water quality outcomes. Although regulation is viewed as necessary to encourage change at the farm level, participants highlighted that it overlooks the complexities of soil, water, and grassland interactions, and provides insufficient support for farmers. Findings underscore the limitations of regulatory compliance alone, pointing factors such as collective responsibility, local ownership, societal pressure, and ecological and hydrological complexity. The article concludes that a more integrated and context-sensitive approach is needed.