Studies of the commons grew out of responses to Hardin's bleak prediction of “tragedy of the commons,” that without state intervention or privatization, any commons will eventually be destroyed by allegedly self-interested users. As such, the commons studies traditionally tend to demonstrate cases where common pool resources (CPR) can be sustainably managed by groups of people beyond the state and market interventions. This paper shows a case from Sulawesi, Indonesia, where a state social forestry program can create a space for the program beneficiaries to build a commons. Through fieldwork that involves participant observation and in-depth interviews with program extension workers and beneficiaries in two social forestry farmer groups, this study found that the program can stimulate beneficiary groups to build collective action in managing the state forest plots admitted to them and that the two groups are the only successful ones among 14 neighboring groups that are involved in the same program. The study also shows that the management of the state-sponsored commons requires extension workers with deep knowledge about local people and landscape, economic incentives, and the flexibility of the local state agency in bending the rules based on bottom-up demands. Therefore, the case study shows that, on the one hand, the state program can actually stimulate the creation of the commons. On the other hand, commoning seems to be the only way to ensure a successful social forestry program.
Water resource politics are often overlooked for jurisdictional perspectives, or difficult to comprehend for the politics unfolding behind the scenes. Using Indonesia as a case study, we synthesized all water-related bureaucracies to generate a list of “Water resource Issue-Elements,” which served as a framework for translating actor-centered power dynamics. The data is based on policies reviewed from 2014 to 2017, coinciding with the beginning of a new presidential administration with heightened interests in water resource management. The study found that while the central coordinating and planning bureaucracies wield the strongest network power, two sectoral bureaucracies hold tremendous influence in guiding water resource management, which unfold under conditions of highly fragmented politics. On the one hand, the Ministry of Environment and Forestry influences water resources through its land management mandate and seeks to enlarge its bureaucratic power beyond state forest boundaries through the concept of watersheds. On the other hand, The Ministry of Public Works and Housing maintains its traditional mandate for managing river basins, wielding large budgets and networks to control information and determine project-related disbursements. As these two bureaucracies shape alliances administering water resources, their delegating responsibilities also refract to regional bureaucracies, shaping a new set of subnational contestations.
Dialektika kepentingan pemerintah daerah dan kepentingan pemerintah pusat dalam sektor kehutanan menjadi topik utama kehutanan saat ini. Pengelolaan sutera alam yang merupakan kepentingan pemerintah daerah telah diasimilasikan kedalam sistem pengelolaan KPH dalam bentuk KPHP Model Awota. Hingga saat ini belum ada kajian ilmiah mengenai potensi pengembangan budidaya sutera alam di ruang lingkup areal KPHP Model Awota. Oleh karena itu penelitian ini bertujuan untuk menganalisis potensi pengembangan sutera alam. Potensi yang dimaksud adalah sistem kelembagaan, potensi biofisik, potensi lingkungan, potensi pasar dan nilai finansial.Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa pengembangan budidaya ulat sutera di areal KPHP Model Awota memiliki keunggulan potensi biofisik, potensi lingkungan, potensi pemasaran dan nilai finansial. Namun, kegiatan ini memliki hambatan berupa persoalan kelembagaan utamanya sistem yang mengatur pengelolaan budidaya ulat sutera dari sektor hulu ke sektor hilir
This study describes the community preferences on land use arrangement in Lekopancing Village, Tanralili Subdistrict, Maros District. The results showed that the preferences of society towards the selection patterns of land use private forest determined by social factors, economic factors, and external factors. Social factors such as success stories of two persons in this village whom earn a large income from the plantation of Gmelina arborea (white teak), which is accompanied by social capital in the form of local knowledge and cultural system based on reciprocity. Economic factors, that is people felt motivated caused by increased income through the white teak plantation. External factors, such as KBR incentive programs and the provision of forestry extension worker, become the driving factors too.
1 May 2019 in IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science
Overlapping of Community Plantation Forest (HTR) reserves with Forest Management Unit (KPH) areas, will create conflict in forest management if the institutional management of HTR is not synergized with KPH institutions. This study aims to form a descriptive model of institutional synergy in the management of HTR within the KPH Awota Area. The study was carried out in the village of Minanga Tellue, Maniangpajo District, Wajo Regency. Field observations, in-depth interviews, Focus Group Discussion (FGD), workshops, and documentation studies were conducted to collect primary and secondary data. Map analysis, institutional analysis, and stakeholder analysis were carried out to achieve the research objectives. The results of the study found a descriptive model of the synergy of forest management institutions, including components: (1) input models in the form of policies, potential, problems, strategic issues, institutions, and stakeholders, (2) management prescriptions include site management and institutional synergy, and (3) model output, namely wood, mulberry and food products. The model needs to be tested and further studied regarding the potential economic efficiency created and the value of economic benefits received by each stakeholder on the implementation of the model.
enormous benefits from an economic, social, and environmental perspective. This contribution was inversely proportional to the trend of changes in the area of HKR, which had decreased. The reduction in the area of HKR was closely related to the socio-economic conditions of the farmers. The purpose of this study is to conduct a socio-economic analysis of HKR management in Maros. This research was conducted in the community candlenut forest area in Maros Regency, including villages with community candlenut forest, including Labuaja, Laiya, Limapoccoe, Rompegading, and Cenrana Baru. This study indicated that there had been a change in the community's social and economic activities in managing the candlenut forest in Maros. Communities tended to focus their livelihoods on cocoa and coffee commodities meanwhile reduce land use for candlenut. The change above is evidenced by the value of community dependence on the candlenut commodity of 35.09%.