The transition of a business to a circular business model (CBM) calls for significant and ongoing shifts in different business management models and strategies. However, there is a lack of research focused on the technological, financial, societal, and institutional influences on the CBM transition in small and/or medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). To address this gap, our study develops a theoretical framework for the transition towards CBM. We conducted a systematic literature review with the objective of determining the relationships among technological, financial, societal, and institutional influences for CBMs. Following this, we then established a conceptual framework that comprises these four key influences for a transition plan in the context of an innovative business model with a focus on the value proposition, value creation, and value delivery. An illustrative case example of the manufacturing industry for the transition plan to CBM was presented as well. The proposed framework is designed to lead the shift towards circular economy-oriented business models that aim to promote sustainability in business. In addition, we uncovered several potential avenues for further investigation. We expect the framework towards both contribute to the expansion of the existing body of research in the field and provide business practitioners with guidelines on the CBMs’ transition for SMEs.
This research explores opportunities for generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) in higher education constituent (customer) relationship management (CRM) to address the industry’s need for digital transformation driven by demographic shifts, economic challenges, and technological advancements. Using a qualitative research approach grounded in the principles of grounded theory, we conducted semi-structured interviews and an open-ended qualitative data collection instrument with technology vendors, implementation consultants, and HEI professionals that are actively exploring GenAI applications. Our findings highlight six primary types of GenAI—textual analysis and synthesis, data summarization, next-best action recommendations, speech synthesis and translation, code development, and image and video creation—each with applications across student recruitment, advising, alumni engagement, and administrative processes. We propose an evaluative framework with eight readiness criteria to assess institutional preparedness for GenAI adoption. While GenAI offers potential benefits, such as increased efficiency, reduced costs, and improved student engagement, its success depends on data readiness, ethical safeguards, and institutional leadership. By integrating GenAI as a co-intelligence alongside human expertise, HEIs can enhance CRM ecosystems and better support their constituents.