Tree size is one of the major factors that determines harvester productivity and is heavily influenced by forest managerial activities. Stand silvicultural management can lead to managing tree size, the distribution of tree size, and tree height amongst others. Understanding the effect of tree size distribution on harvesting productivity is central for optimizing management of operations. To investigate the effects of tree size distribution on harvester productivity, productivity functions for a medium and larger-sized harvester were applied to harvester derived tree size distributions from 35 clearfelled pine stands. These functions were applied to a normal distribution of trees covering the same tree size ranges. Productivity differences were analysed on a stand-by-stand basis. Results showed that for the larger harvester, productivity rates remained constant (67.1 vs. 67.6 m3·PMH− 1) indicating relatively little sensitivity to variations in tree size distributions. Although the standard deviation (SD) halved from 11.6 to 5.6 in the case of the uniform tree distribution. The smaller harvester productivity decreased by 15% from 47.3 to 40.1 m3·PMH− 1 and the coefficient of variation (CV) by 6% in the same transition to a uniform distribution. Further investigation was done on more skewed tree size distributions, a family of nine Weibull distributions was generated, representing combinations of three mean DBH classes (25 cm, 30 cm, and 35 cm) and three levels of CV (15%, 20%, 25%), for each DBH class. Results clearly indicate that different distribution shapes have different effects on different machine sizes, and that a low CV correlates to a higher productivity in larger tree sizes. A more uniform tree size distribution also provides more predictable results (lower CV), which would promote machine scheduling and result in fewer discrepancies on production rates.
The Electric Vehicle Scheduling Problem (E-VSP) addresses the challenge of efficiently assigning predetermined trips to an electric vehicle fleet while accounting for charging infrastructure and battery range constraints. Despite numerous optimisation approaches proposed in the literature, comparative analyses of these methods remain scarce, with researchers typically focusing on developing novel algorithms rather than evaluating existing algorithms. Moreover, studies often employ convenient assumptions tailored to improve the performance of their optimisation technique. This study presents a comprehensive comparison of several optimisation techniques (mixed integer linear programming (MILP) using the branch-and-cut algorithm, metaheuristics, and heuristics) applied to the E-VSP under identical assumptions and constraints. The techniques are evaluated across multiple metrics, including solution quality, computational efficiency, and implementation complexity. Findings reveal that the branch-and-cut algorithm cannot solve instances with more than 10 trips in a reasonable time. Among metaheuristics, only genetic algorithms and simulated annealing demonstrate competitive performance, but both struggle with instances exceeding 100 trips. Our recently developed heuristic algorithm consistently found better solutions in significantly shorter computation times than the metaheuristics due to its ability to efficiently navigate the solution space while respecting the unique constraints of the E-VSP.
1 July 2008 in Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory
Ranking and selection (R&S) procedures form an important research field in computer simulation and its applications. In simulation, one usually has to select the best from a number of scenarios or alternative designs. Often, the simulated processes have a stochastic nature, which means that, to distinguish alternatives, they must exhibit significant statistical differences. R&S procedures assist the decision-maker with the selection of the best alternative with high confidence. This paper reviews past and current R&S procedures. The review traces back to the 1950s, when the first R&S procedure was proposed, and discusses the various R&S procedures proposed since then to the present day, presenting a cursory view of the research in the area. The review includes studies in both the single-objective and the multi-objective domains. It presents the research trend, discusses specific issues, and gives recommendations for future research in both domains.
1 December 2016 in South African Journal of Industrial Engineering