Maria Bajwa

Dr. Maria Bajwa

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

4Years (2023-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
4 January 2023 in Simulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MBMaria Bajwa
Maria Bajwa
RARami Do Ahmed
Rami Do Ahmed
HLHani MD Lababidi
Hani MD Lababidi
MMMelissa Msn Morris
Melissa Msn Morris
AMAlex PhD Morton
Alex PhD Morton
JPJanice C. PhD Palaganas
Janice C. PhD Palaganas
Introduction: The abrupt disruption of in-person instruction in health care during the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in the rapid adoption of distance simulation as an immediate alternative to providing in-person simulation-based education. This massive instructional shift, combined with the lack of educator training in this domain, led to challenges for both learners and educators. This study aimed to disseminate the first set of competencies required of and unique to effective distance simulation educators. Methods: This was a multiphasic and iterative modified Delphi study validating the content of carefully and rigorously synthesized literature. Experts were invited from around the globe to participate in this study with mandatory attendance at an annual health care simulation conference to openly discuss the guidelines presented as competencies in this document. We divided each competency into “Basic” and “Advanced” levels, and agreement was sought for these levels individually. The experts provided their opinion by choosing the options of “Keep, Modify, or Delete.” A free-marginal kappa of 0.60 was chosen a priori. Results: At the conclusion of the Delphi process, the number of competencies changed from 66 to 59, basic subcompetencies from 216 to 196, and advanced subcompetencies from 179 to 182. Conclusions: This article provides the first set of consensus guidelines to distance simulation educators in health care, and paved the way for further research in distance simulation as a modality.

27 December 2024 in Cureus
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MBMaria Bajwa
Maria Bajwa
FNFizza Najeeb
Fizza Najeeb
HAHaneen Alnazzawi
Haneen Alnazzawi
AAAyesha Ayub
Ayesha Ayub
JBJessica G. Bell
Jessica G. Bell
FSFouzia Sadiq
Fouzia Sadiq
Healthcare simulation has gained global recognition in health professions education, yet its adoption in Pakistan, a lower-middle-income country (LMIC), remains limited. This scoping review aimed to explore how simulation is integrated into healthcare education in Pakistan, highlighting challenges and opportunities to inform similar LMICs. Pakistan serves as a critical case study for LMICs due to its unique challenges, including uneven access to simulation technologies and limited faculty training, which are shared by many similar resource-constrained settings. Using the Arksey and O’Malley framework, a systematic review of 693 publications identified 145 studies that met inclusion criteria. The findings revealed diverse simulation modalities primarily focused on skills training and clinical decision-making. Notable innovations included low-cost simulation solutions, effectively addressing resource constraints. However, significant gaps emerged, including an urban-centric focus with limited rural representation, insufficient evaluation of long-term impacts, and the absence of standardized terminology and training protocols. These challenges hinder broader integration and equitable access to simulation-based learning. Addressing these gaps through strategic collaborations, capacity-building initiatives, and innovative, cost-effective solutions, such as low-cost simulators crafted from readily available materials, could enhance simulation adoption in Pakistan and similar LMICs. This review highlights the importance of adopting evidence-based practices, increasing funding, and conducting comprehensive research on simulation's long-term impact to ensure effective implementation and improved healthcare education and outcomes globally.

31 May 2024 in OJIN: The Online Journal of Issues in Nursing
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JLJan Lee
Jan Lee
LLLaura Logan
Laura Logan
EPEdmund Pajarillo
Edmund Pajarillo
VKValerie Kubanick
Valerie Kubanick
FBFrederick Brown
Frederick Brown
MBMaria Bajwa
Maria Bajwa
The nursing shortage continues to grow, leaving healthcare systems and patients in a precarious situation. A major reason for the shortage is the lack of nursing faculty to educate future nurses, which has hindered nursing programs nationwide from accepting students interested in a nursing career. This qualitative study explored the existing academic nurse educator shortage and sought solutions that an important stakeholder group, the public and business sector/business owners, might implement to mitigate the dual shortage of professional nurses and academic nurse educators. Using a modified Nominal Group Technique (NGT) design, the research team identified five major stakeholder groups which could benefit from addressing the academic nurse educator shortage. Team subgroups reviewed relevant literature and crafted recommendations to address the academic nurse educator shortage. This article discusses findings from one of these major stakeholders: the public and business/business owner sectors. Forty-five academic nurse educators were recruited from volunteers engaged in a national nursing education online forum and 25 participants completed the study. Five themes emerged: encourage lobbying efforts with legislators; engage the media in exposing the relationship of the academic nurse educator shortage and the nursing shortage; incentivize higher education opportunities for nurses to become academic nurse educators; elevate the life experience of patients; and stakeholder collaboration. A continued partnership between the public/business sectors/business owners and leaders within the profession of nursing must exist to enhance the academic nurse educator role. Only with this partnership can those within the profession of nursing continue to serve the public sustainably for years to come.

27 April 2026 in JMIRx Med
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MBMaria Bajwa
Maria Bajwa
RHRobert Hoyt
Robert Hoyt
DKDacre Knight
Dacre Knight
MHMaruf Haider
Maruf Haider
Background: Generative artificial intelligence models, especially reasoning large language models (LLMs), are gaining adoption in health care for diagnostic decision support and medical education. DeepSeek R1 is a reasoning LLM that generates extended chain-of-thought explanations to make its decision-making process more explicit. Traditional medical benchmarks often lack complexity and authenticity, motivating the adoption of scenario-rich datasets, such as the Massive Multitask Language Understanding Pro (MMLU-Pro) professional medicine subset, which provides multispecialty clinical vignettes for reasoning-centric evaluation. Objective: The objective of this study is to assess the diagnostic accuracy, reasoning quality, reasoning transparency, and practical usability of DeepSeek R1 and Gemini 3 Pro across closed- and open-ended clinical scenarios, with the intention of guiding their prospective application in practical clinical education and training. This evaluation was conducted by analyzing 162 diverse medical scenarios (both closed- and open-ended) from the MMLU-Pro health subset. Methods: In a 2-phase, dual-model evaluation, DeepSeek R1 and Gemini 3 Pro were applied to 162 matched clinical vignettes from the MMLU-Pro professional medicine subset spanning 21 specialties. Closed-ended, multiple-choice, and open-ended prompts were constructed for the same scenarios, and model outputs were coded for accuracy, reasoning steps, and citation behavior; descriptive statistics and the McNemar test were used to compare performance across formats. Results: DeepSeek R1 achieved an accuracy of 86.4% (140/162 scenarios) on closed-ended tasks and 80.9% (131/162) on open-ended questions across 162 clinical scenarios, indicating modest attenuation of performance when answer cues were removed. Gemini 3 Pro demonstrated 90.7% (147/162) closed-ended and 88.9% (144/162) open-ended accuracy on the same scenarios, showing a similar pattern of decreased performance without answer options. Error analysis indicated that incorrect answers typically involved longer reasoning chains, suggesting overthinking. In a structured review of open-ended responses, DeepSeek R1 produced an average of 18.7 (range 0‐52) references per case, with 5.2 unrelated references and 13.1 (range 3‐67) reasoning steps, whereas Gemini 3 Pro averaged 22.5 (range 12‐50) references, 1.9 (range 0‐8) unrelated references, and 4.4 (range 1‐10) reasoning steps per case. Conclusions: DeepSeek R1 demonstrated moderate-to-excellent accuracy and reasoning in evaluating both closed- and open-ended medical scenarios. In parallel, Gemini 3 Pro showed broadly comparable but distinct performance and reasoning patterns. While the closed-ended format may inflate accuracy due to cueing, the open-ended evaluation yielded richer insights into the fidelity of reasoning. Side-by-side evaluation of two large reasoning models highlights the importance of format, specialty, and citation behavior when considering clinical and educational use. Continued validation across a wider range of specialties and real-world contexts will enhance the model’s trustworthiness for diagnostic and teaching applications.

6 July 2023 in International Journal of Healthcare Simulation
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MBMaria Bajwa
Maria Bajwa
AKAdeel Khatri
Adeel Khatri
SASaima Ali
Saima Ali
RARami Ahmed
Rami Ahmed
MEMuhammed Elhady Muhammed Elgasim
Muhammed Elhady Muhammed Elgasim
JFJabeen Fayyaz
Jabeen Fayyaz
Introduction Professional development in simulation-based education (SBE) is a complex process. Individual components have overlapping boundaries and relationships, rendering them suitable for Complex Adaptive Systems (CAS). This complexity is multifold in low-resource settings, unfamiliar with simulation, and augmented by hierarchical culture and linguistic diversity. This study aimed to conduct a professional development course through SBE using principles of CAS for faculty in a Pakistani medical college. Methods A simulation educator team (six on-site, three online) from Pakistan and North America constructed and facilitated a 6-hour-long hybrid course following CAS in three phases. Planning phase consisted of needs assessment and inclusion of stakeholders in decision-making. Implementation phase involved remote facilitators joining the in-person team using Zoom and demonstrating evidence-based practices in case design, pre-briefing, facilitation and debriefing. In the evaluation phase, participants completed an immediate Post-workshop Survey and a Follow-up Survey after 4 weeks. Results Twenty-three faculty members from basic medical (n = 9) and clinical sciences (n = 14) participated in the course and completed the evaluations. All five outcomes intended for this program, i.e., level of acceptance for simulation, simulation knowledge, self-efficacy, simulation application in the learner’s setting and performance of workshop facilitators, were met. The unexpected positive outcome was smooth delivery of the program from an administrative perspective and enthusiastic response from learners towards simulation. Discussion We suggest using CAS as a framework for professional development programs to train faculty in simulation. A CAS framework can help the organizers to integrate systems thinking into educational interventions. Introduction Professional development in simulation-based education (SBE) is a complex process. Individual components have overlapping boundaries and relationships, rendering them suitable for Complex Adaptive Systems (CAS). This complexity is multifold in low-resource settings, unfamiliar with simulation, and augmented by hierarchical culture and linguistic diversity. This study aimed to conduct a professional development course through SBE using principles of CAS for faculty in a Pakistani medical college. Methods A simulation educator team (six on-site, three online) from Pakistan and North America constructed and facilitated a 6-hour-long hybrid course following CAS in three phases. Planning phase consisted of needs assessment and inclusion of stakeholders in decision-making. Implementation phase involved remote facilitators joining the in-person team using Zoom and demonstrating evidence-based practices in case design, pre-briefing, facilitation and debriefing. In the evaluation phase, participants completed an immediate Post-workshop Survey and a Follow-up Survey after 4 weeks. Results Twenty-three faculty members from basic medical (n = 9) and clinical sciences (n = 14) participated in the course and completed the evaluations. All five outcomes intended for this program, i.e., level of acceptance for simulation, simulation knowledge, self-efficacy, simulation application in the learner’s setting and performance of workshop facilitators, were met. The unexpected positive outcome was smooth delivery of the program from an administrative perspective and enthusiastic response from learners towards simulation. Discussion We suggest using CAS as a framework for professional development programs to train faculty in simulation. A CAS framework can help the organizers to integrate systems thinking into educational interventions.

7 April 2025 in medRxiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
RHRobert Hoyt
Robert Hoyt
DKDacre Knight
Dacre Knight
MHMaruf Haider
Maruf Haider
MBMaria Bajwa
Maria Bajwa
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a major force in artificial intelligence, demonstrating remarkable capabilities in natural language processing, comprehension, and text and image generation. Recent advancements have led to the development of LLMs specifically designed for medical applications, showcasing their potential to revolutionize healthcare. These models can analyze complex medical scenarios, assist in diagnoses, and provide treatment recommendations. However, evaluating the accuracy and reliability of LLMs in medicine remains a crucial challenge. The output may not be current and could suffer from inaccurate information, known as hallucinations. In early 2025, DeepSeek R1 was released, which is a large reasoning model (LRM) that includes the “chain of thought” reasoning that made it more transparent than any LLM that preceded it. This study utilized the new MMLU-Pro benchmark, which is a more complex Q&A dataset compared to the Massive Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU). DeepSeek R1 was used to analyze the Q&A dataset primarily for accuracy, but medical scenario Q&As are only one facet of a comprehensive assessment. The study found that DeepSeek R1 had an accuracy rate of 96.3% on 162 medical scenarios after reconciliation with subject matter experts on 23 questions. Our findings contribute to the growing body of knowledge on LLM applications in healthcare and provide insights into the strengths and limitations of DeepSeek R1 in this domain. DeepSeek R1 demonstrates excellent accuracy along with unique transparency. Our analysis also highlights the need for multifaceted evaluation methods that go beyond simple accuracy metrics to ensure the safe and effective deployment of LLMs in medical settings.