This paper identifies and analyses the legitimation strategies used by the OECD as it expanded its role in global educational governance. Whilst the literature recognises the mainly discursive sources of legitimacy which the OECD derives from its testing regime, especially PISA, what remains unexplored is how exactly it has created the legitimacy to monitor SDG 4 – an arena where it has not been previously involved. Drawing on Suchman’s framework for analysing organisational legitimacy, we identify six strategies. We show how these: were used to promote the OECD’s pragmatic, moral, and cognitive legitimacy; progressed over time from low-key passive conformity to active manipulation; and, operated on both an episodic and a continual basis.
This paper develops the argument that, in the application of AI to improve the system of governance for higher education, machine learning will be more effective in some areas than others. To make that assertion more systematic, a classificatory taxonomy of types of decisions is necessary. This paper draws upon the classification of decision processes as either symbolic or sub-symbolic. Symbolic approaches focus on whole system design and emphasise logical coherence across sub-systems, while sub-symbolic approaches emphasise localised decision making with distributed engagement, at the expense of overall coherence. AI, especially generative AI, is argued to be best suited to working at the sub-symbolic level, although there are exceptions when discriminative AI systems are designed symbolically. The paper then uses Beer’s Viable System Model to identify whether the decisions necessary for viability are best approached symbolically or sub-symbolically. The need for leadership to recognise when a sub-symbolic system is failing and requires symbolic intervention is a specific case where human intervention may be necessary to override the conclusions of an AI system. The paper presents an initial analysis of which types of AI would support which functions of governance best, and explains why ultimate control must always rest with human leaders.