The need for the public to take an active role in scientific research is becoming increasingly important, particularly in health-related research. However, the coexistence and alignment of scientific and citizen interests, needs, knowledge and timing is not straightforward, especially when involving migrant populations. To conduct impactful research, it becomes also essential to consider the perspectives of policymakers, thereby adding a layer of complexity to the processes. In this article we address the experience of a living lab created in a research institution and supported by the city council and a local foundation, in which we developed three experiences of patient and public involvement (PPI): (1) accessing to comprehensive care for people at risk of Chagas disease; (2) strategies towards improving access and quality of mental healthcare services in migrants; (3) promoting healthy and safe school environments in vulnerable urban settings. These three challenges provided an opportunity to delve into diverse strategies for involving key stakeholders, including migrant populations, expert researchers and political actors in health research. This article offers insights into the successes, challenges, and valuable lessons learnt from these endeavours, providing a vision that can be beneficial for future initiatives. Each living lab experience crafted its unique governance system and agenda tailored to specific challenge scenarios, giving rise to diverse methods and study designs. We have found that the management of the cocreation of the research question and the institutional support are key to building robust PPI processes with migrant groups.
16 August 2021 in Journal of Science Communication
A Science Shop acts as a mission-oriented intermediary unit between the scientific sphere and civil society organizations. It seeks to facilitate citizen-driven open science projects that respond to the needs of civil society organizations and which, typically, include students in the work process. We performed a thematic analysis of a systematically selected literature on Science Shops to understand how the scientific literature reflects the historical evolution of Science Shops in different settings and what factors the literature associates with the rise and fall of the Science Shop. We used the PRISMA methodology to search for scientific papers in indexed journals in eight databases published in English, French and Spanish, and employed the thematic theory approach to extract and systematize our results. Twenty-six scientific articles met the inclusion criteria. We identified three meta-categories and ten sub-topics which can serve as key pointers to guide the set-up and future work of Science Shops. Our results identify a major paradox: Science Shops incorporate public values in their scientific agendas but have difficulties sustaining themselves institutionally as they do not fit the current dominant research paradigm. Science shops represent a persuasive complementary approach to the way science is defined, executed and produced today.
25 November 2019 in Lecture Notes in Computer Science
Background/Objectives: Nowadays, endometriosis is considered a chronic inflammatory disease and has a very high impact on women who suffer from it due to the symptoms of pain and infertility, as well as the delay in diagnosis. The objective of our study was to identify the unmet needs of endometriosis patients and to explore opportunities for improvement with respect to health care services for endometriosis patients using a patient training workshop. Methods: A qualitative study with a participatory action research method was performed. A two-day training workshop for patients was designed to allow them to develop the confidence and skills necessary to participate in the identification of unmet needs in their healthcare. Eighteen patients were selected by purposive sampling. After each training session, a debate on a topic of interest was also organized among all the participants. Data collection involved the nominal group technique with triangulation of data for their analysis. Results: The suggestions brought up during the sessions were divided into four areas of work: improvement of patient care, information and communication, training of professionals/patients, and encouragement of patients to participate. This study is a successful novel example of co-production with endometriosis patients and health care professionals and provides valuable information for future improvements in the care of these patients. Conclusions: Co-production between endometriosis patients and healthcare professionals allowed us to identify unmet needs in their healthcare.
9 May 2022 in Anuario de Psicología/the Ub Journal of Psychology
Con el objetivo de conocer los argumentos de profesionales de la salud mental en torno al ejercicio y/o vulneración de los derechos sexuales y reproductivos (DSR) de las mujeres con diagnóstico en trastorno mental grave (DTMG) y establecer prioridades para la investigación en intervención dentro del área, aplicamos el método Delphi para la obtención de información y un análisis del contenido temático para su análisis.Los resultados evidencian como el género interactúa con el estigma social asociado al DTMG como elementos que posicionan a las mujeres en situaciones de vulnerabilidad social, los cuales tienen efectos negativos sobre el ejercicio de sus DSR. Estos efectos están presentes tanto en el área de la sexualidad, caracterizada por el tabú y la medicalización, como en el área de la reproducción, caracterizada por la mirada incapacitante en torno a la maternidad y el control reproductivo. Asimismo, sitúan a las mujeres en posiciones de opresión que favorecen situaciones de abusos y maltratos.Se concluye destacando los elementos clave para la comprensión del fenómeno, los cuales serán de utilidad para el desarrollo de futuros análisis en el área: el estigma del DTMG, el ejercicio del poder simbólico sobre la construcción de la subjetividad y la reproducción de la exclusión social. Finalmente, proponemos líneas de acción social orientadas a revisar los recursos, el reconocimiento de la agencia de las mujeres con DTMG, y el establecimiento de procesos donde participen el saber científico y profesional, las mujeres y sus familias.
Participatory research can be promoted by scientific intermediary units, such as Science Shops. The overarching goal of these initiatives is thereby to foster a process of co-creation of the research questions to address societal needs that are relevant to scientific research and society at large. The InSPIRES project was a Horizon Europe initiative from 2017 to 2021 with the primary objective of expanding the implementation of Science Shops across Europe and internationally. Within the framework of this project, a harmonized, self-reflection and impact assessment methodology has been developed to evaluate five dimensions of participatory research: knowledge democracy, citizen-led research, participatory dynamics, integrity, and transformative change. In this article, we report the results of 58 projects implemented in Africa, Asia and Europe. We present the results of quantitative and qualitative data analysis with a view towards encouraging the debate on the challenges involved in designing a standardized evaluation tool to capture the multiplicity of processes involved in participatory research. Results showed that the participatory research processes increase access to knowledge and promote the forging of alliances and relations of trust through respectful dialogue from multiple standpoints. The analysis also retraces some critical points with regard to the democratization of knowledge and the scope for social transformation, which would require further scrutiny. All in all, the proposed InSPIRES assessment tool proved to be a straightforward approach to systematically evaluate key dimensions of participatory research across different phases and project roles that could serve as a starting point for future similar initiatives.