Deficiencies in TH1-type immunity in patients with cancer may facilitate tumor progression and limit the effectiveness of current immunotherapy approaches. We hypothesized that Type-1 polarized dendritic cells (DC1) might be able to recondition patient antitumor CD4+ T cell responses toward the TH1-type in vitro. Although DC1 have been previously demonstrated to prime TH1 responses from naive CD4+ T cells, their impact on antigen-experienced TH responses remains unknown. We confirmed our own earlier observations that patient CD4+ T cell reactivity against melanoma-associated antigens (MAA) was weaker and less Type-1-polarized than their corresponding antiviral responses. Stimulation of patient CD4 T cells with peptide-pulsed DC1 (producing multiple IL-12 family member cytokines, including IL-12p70, IL-23, and IL-27) promoted robust TH1-type, epitope-specific T cell responses. Addition of exogenous IL-12 family member cytokines alone, or in combination, to nonpolarized DC was insufficient to equate to the benefits associated with DC1-based stimulation; however, IL-27 and IL-12p70 blockade neutralized the ability of DC1 cells to enhance TH1-type antitumor immunity in vitro. Notably, DC1-based stimulation seemed capable of "revitalizing" defective TH1-type responses within the CD45RO+ subset of antigen-experienced CD4+ T cells in melanoma patients. In addition to promoting elevated levels of IFN-gamma from responder CD4+ T cells, DC1-based stimulation also led to increased levels of IL-12Rbeta2 and t-bet expression by TH cells. These results suggest that preexisting CD4+ T cell immunity to cancer is not relegated to Type-1 insufficiency and may be corrected via the application of DC1-based vaccination protocols.

The EphA2 receptor tyrosine kinase is an attractive therapeutic target that is commonly overexpressed on solid tumors, with the degree of overexpression associated with disease progression, metastatic potential, and poor prognosis. Agonistic mAbs or ligand (ephrinA1)-Fc fusion protein are capable of inducing EphA2 internalization and degradation, thereby (at least transiently) eliminating the influence of this oncoprotein. We and others have also shown that EphA2 contains multiple peptide epitopes that can be recognized by effector CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T cells isolated from tumor-bearing patients. Herein, we show that “agonist” reagents that trigger the proteasome-dependent degradation of tumor cell EphA2 result in the improved presentation of peptides derived from (both the extracellular and intracellular domains of) EphA2 in MHC class I complexes expressed on the tumor cell membrane for at least 48 h, as manifested by increased recognition by EphA2-specific CD8⁺ T cells in vitro. We also observed that while delivery of ephrinA1-Fc fusion protein or agonist mAb into EphA2⁺ tumor lesions promotes EphA2 degradation in situ, this single administration of agent does not dramatically alter tumor progression in a humanized SCID model. However, when combined with the adoptive transfer of normally nontherapeutic (human) anti-EphA2 CD8⁺ CTL, this dual-agent regimen results in complete tumor eradication. These results suggest that strategies targeting the conditional proteasome-mediated destruction of tumor cell EphA2 may enable EphA2-specific CD8⁺ T cells (of modest functional avidity) to realize improved therapeutic potential.

Multivalent second-generation TRAIL-R2 agonists are currently in late preclinical development and early clinical trials. Herein, we use a representative second-generation agent, MEDI3039, to address two major clinical challenges facing these agents: lack of predictive biomarkers to enable patient selection and emergence of resistance. Genome-wide CRISPR knockout screens were notable for the lack of resistance mechanisms beyond the canonical TRAIL-R2 pathway (caspase-8, FADD, BID) as well as p53 and BAX in TP53 wild-type models, whereas a CRISPR activatory screen identified cell death inhibitors MCL-1 and BCL-XL as mechanisms to suppress MEDI3039-induced cell death. High-throughput drug screening failed to identify genomic alterations associated with response to MEDI3039; however, transcriptomics analysis revealed striking association between MEDI3039 sensitivity and expression of core components of the extrinsic apoptotic pathway, most notably its main apoptotic effector caspase-8 in solid tumor cell lines. Further analyses of colorectal cell lines and patient-derived xenografts identified caspase-8 expression ratio to its endogenous regulator FLIP(L) as predictive of sensitivity to MEDI3039 in several major solid tumor types and a further subset indicated by caspase-8:MCL-1 ratio. Subsequent MEDI3039 combination screening of TRAIL-R2, caspase-8, FADD, and BID knockout models with 60 compounds with varying mechanisms of action identified two inhibitor of apoptosis proteins (IAP) that exhibited strong synergy with MEDI3039 that could reverse resistance only in BID-deleted models. In summary, we identify the ratios of caspase-8:FLIP(L) and caspase-8:MCL-1 as potential predictive biomarkers for second-generation TRAIL-R2 agonists and loss of key effectors such as FADD and caspase-8 as likely drivers of clinical resistance in solid tumors.

Adoptive cellular therapies are making major strides in the treatment of cancer, both for hematologic and solid tumors. These cellular products include chimeric antigen receptor T cells and T-cell receptor–modified T cells, tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes, marrow-infiltrating T cells, natural killer cells as well as macrophage-based therapeutics. Advancement in genomics, computational biology, immunology, and cell therapy manufacturing has facilitated advancement of adoptive T cell therapies into the clinic, whereas clinical efficacy has driven Food and Drug Administration approvals. The growth of adoptive cellular therapy has, in turn, led to innovation in the preclinical models available, from ex vivo cell-based models to in vivo xenograft models of treatment. This review focuses on the development and application of in vitro models and in vivo models (cell line xenograft, humanized mice, and patient-derived xenograft models) that directly evaluate these human cellular products.

Supplementary Figure from Functional Genomic Identification of Predictors of Sensitivity and Mechanisms of Resistance to Multivalent Second-Generation TRAIL-R2 Agonists

In vivo expression of CASP8 and CFLAR (FLIP) modulate response to MEDI3039 in PDX models. A, Change in percent tumor growth from baseline was measured at day 18 in 18 CRC PDX models treated with a fixed dose of MEDI3039. B, Tumor plots of responder, nonresponder, and partial response models. x-axis, days; y-axis, tumor volume. Arrows indicate treatment with MEDI3039. Red line, MEDI039-treated mice; blue line, untreated mice. C, Tumor CASP8 mRNA expression in PDX nonresponders (red) and responders (blue) with MEDI3039 (each circle represents a tumor from a single mouse). D, Comparison of CASP8:CFLAR ratio in MEDI3039 responder (blue) and nonresponder (red) PDX models.