Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest is a major health problem, and immediate treatment is essential for improving the chances of survival. The development of technological solutions to detect out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and alert emergency responders is gaining momentum; multiple research consortia are currently developing wearable technology for this purpose. For the responsible design and implementation of this technology, it is necessary to attend to the ethical implications. This review identifies relevant ethical aspects of wearable-based out-of-hospital cardiac arrest detection according to four key principles of medical ethics. First, aspects related to beneficence concern the effectiveness of the technology. Second, nonmaleficence requires preventing psychological distress associated with wearing the device and raises questions about the desirability of screening. Third, grounded in autonomy are empowerment, the potential reidentification from continuously collected data, issues of data access, bystander privacy, and informed consent. Finally, justice concerns include the risks of algorithmic bias and unequal technology access. Based on this overview and relevant legislation, we formulate design recommendations. We suggest that key elements are device accuracy and reliability, dynamic consent, purpose limitation, and personalization. Further empirical research is needed into the perspectives of stakeholders, including people at risk of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and their next-of-kin, to achieve a successful and ethically balanced integration of this technology in society.
15 January 2018 in Journal of Clinical and Translational Research
Systems based on artificial intelligence and machine learning that facilitate decision making in health care are promising new tools in the era of ‘personalized’ or ‘precision’ medicine. As the volume of patient data and scientific evidence grows, these computerised decision support systems (DSS) have great potential to help healthcare professionals improve diagnosis and care for individual patients. However, the implementation of these tools in clinical care raises some foreseeable legal challenges for healthcare providers and DSS-suppliers in Europe: How does the use of complex and novel DSS relate to professional standards to provide a reasonable standard of care? What should be done in terms of testing before DSS can be used in regular practice? What are the potential liabilities of health care providers and DSS companies if a DSS fails to function well? How do legal requirements for the protection of patient data and general privacy rights apply to likely DSS scenarios? In this article, we provide an overview of the current law and its general implications for the use of DSS, from a European perspective. We conclude that healthcare providers and DSS-suppliers will have the best chance of meeting legal challenges if: they are first tested in translational research with the patients' explicit, informed consent; DSS-suppliers and healthcare providers are able to clarify and agree on their individual legal responsibilities, and; patients are properly informed about privacy risks and able to decide themselves whether their data can be used for other purposes, or are stored and processed outside the EU. DSS developers and healthcare providers will need to work together closely to ensure compliance with national and European regulations and standards required for reasonable and safe patient care. Relevance to patients: Advanced digital decision support systems have the potential to improve patient diagnosis and care. In this article we discuss key legal issues to support translational research using DSS and ensure that they meet the high standards for protection of patient safety and privacy in Europe.
Learning healthcare systems have recently emerged as a strategy to continuously use experiences and outcomes of clinical care for research purposes in precision medicine. Although it is known that learning healthcare transitions in general raise important ethical challenges, the ethical ramifications of such transitions in the specific context of precision medicine have not extensively been discussed. Here, we describe three levers that institutions can pull to advance learning healthcare systems in precision medicine: (1) changing testing of individual variability (such as genes); (2) changing prescription of treatments on the basis of (genomic) test results; and/or (3) changing the handling of data that link variability and treatment to clinical outcomes. Subsequently, we evaluate how patients can be affected if one of these levers are pulled: (1) patients are tested for different or more factors than before the transformation, (2) patients receive different treatments than before the transformation and/or (3) patients’ data obtained through clinical care are used, or used more extensively, for research purposes. Based on an analysis of the aforementioned mechanisms and how these potentially affect patients, we analyze why learning healthcare systems in precision medicine need a different ethical approach and discuss crucial points to consider regarding this approach.
According to the Declaration of Helsinki, participation of human subjects in medical research is only acceptable if subjects have given their consent. But in child abuse and neglect, many studies use a design in which subjects do not actively participate. Data in these studies are gathered from sources such as medical records or Child Protective Services. As long as such data are used anonymously, this does not interfere with individual privacy rights. However, some research is only possible when carried out with personally identifiable data, which could potentially be misused. In this paper, we discuss in which situations and under which conditions personal data of children may be used for a study without obtaining consent. In doing so, we make use of two recent studies, performed in our hospital, in which we encountered this issue. Both studies involved collecting personal data. After careful consideration, we decided not to ask informed consent; instead, we arranged for specific safeguards to protect the subject's and their parents' privacy as well as possible. Altogether, we conclude that our approach fits within the Dutch legal framework and seems a reasonable solution in situations in which individual privacy rights are at odds with the public interest of child abuse and neglect research. We argue that, although, in principle, data research is only acceptable after informed consent is obtained, the law should allow that, under specific circumstances and safeguards, this requirement is put aside to make research in the field of child abuse and neglect possible. • In principle, data research is only acceptable after informed consent is obtained.• In practice, this is not always feasible. • Under specific circumstances and safeguards, the informed consent requirement can be put aside.
Stem cell-derived (SCD)-gametes derived from induced or autologous (i.e. patient-specific) cells may help mitigate human fertility problems caused by physiological or social factors in the (near) future. While this technology is still in its infancy, recent advancements with SCD-gametes generated from mouse pluripotent stem cells have led some researchers to expect—and investors to anticipate—the clinical introduction of human gametes derived from induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCD-gametes) within two decades. However, it remains to be investigated how realistic these expectations are, and how they would balance against careful consideration of technical, ethical, legal, and societal aspects, including—but not limited to—safety and effectiveness. This mini-review aims to encourage that investigation by providing a brief overview of the state-of-the-art and highlighting the breadth of issues involved in the potential clinical introduction of human iPSCD-gametes. These issues emerge before (Stage 1), during (Stage 2), and after (Stage 3) clinical trials, and are discussed in that order. Issues discussed in the context of Stage 1 suggest that gathering the evidence required to preclinically assess the safety of human iPSCD-gametes will be time-consuming and require parallel experiments with sensitive research materials. Issues discussed in the context of Stage 2 suggest that it might take several years for human iPSCD-gametes to transition through distinct clinical trial phases, and that inevitable (and unforeseeable) variations in the quality of human iPSCD-gametes are likely to further slow this down. Finally, issues discussed in the context of Stage 3 suggest that offering human iPSCD-gametes clinically will require addressing questions of accountability and monitoring, some of which might be difficult to formalize by law. Combined, these findings suggest that a responsible clinical introduction of human iPSCD-gametes may take considerably longer than expected, underscoring the importance of transdisciplinary collaborations with a broad range of stakeholders to make well-informed and well-considered choices about their development and application.
Investigator-initiated clinical trials are crucial for improving quality of care for children and pregnant women as they are often excluded from industry-initiated trials. However, trials have become increasingly time-consuming and costly since the EU Clinical Trial Directive entered into force in 2001. This directive made compliance with ICH-Good Clinical Practice Guidelines (ethical and quality standard for conducting human subject research) mandatory for all clinical trials, regardless of its risk-classification. By discussing two investigator-initiated, ‘low-risk’ drug trials, we aim to illustrate that compliance with all GCP requirements makes trials very laborious and expensive, while a clear rationale is missing. This discourages clinical researchers to start and carry out investigator-initiated research. However, the forthcoming EU Clinical Trial Regulation (No 536/2014) seems to provide a solution as it allows for less stringent rules for low-risk trials. We want to raise awareness for these developments in both the clinical research community and the European and national regulatory authorities. Implementation of this forthcoming Regulation regulatory policies should be done in such a way that investigator-initiated trials evaluating standard care interventions will become more feasible. This will allow us to obtain evidence on optimal and safe treatments, especially for groups that are underrepresented in medical research. What is Known• Investigator-initiated trials are indispensable for improving care for children and pregnant women as they are often excluded from industry-initiated trials• Trials have become increasingly time-consuming and costly because of mandatory compliance with ICH-GCP guidelinesWhat is New• The forthcoming EU Clinical Trial Regulation allows less stringent rules for low-risk trials• The national legislator and regulatory authorities should recognize the importance of this opportunity and implement the Regulation in such a way that investigator-initiated trials will become more feasible