Orientation: The Income Tax Act has tax consequences for both the debtor and the creditor when a debt is waived as a result of a concession or compromise. This article focuses on the income tax implications for the debtor.Research purpose: Even though symmetry is achieved when calculating the tax implications for the debtor, it causes inconvenience and economic hardship. The research identified examples of where deferral relief has been granted in the Income Tax Act, and this is used as a motivation to extend similar relief for the distressed debtor.Motivation for the study: Companies were already trading under tough economic conditions before the advent of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) The pandemic has compounded the situation and introduced new challenges; hence, debt waivers have become increasingly prevalent.Research approach/design and method: A qualitative research methodology was applied using the doctrinal approach in conducting the research.Main findings: Where a debt is waived in a company that is already in financial distress, this may lead to a recoupment and or capital gains that trigger immediate tax consequences for the company.Practical/managerial implications: The recoupment and/or capital gain, which is subject to tax, creates undue hardship, inconvenience on the already distressed debtor and further impacts the ability of South African Revenue Service (SARS) to collect the tax debt.Contribution/value-add: The authors seek to rectify the identified problem by suggesting that a legislative amendment be introduced to allow the distressed taxpayer relief through a deferral of inclusion in taxable income.
20 November 2019 in South African Journal of Accounting Research
Apartheid in South Africa left a legacy of inequality in every sphere – political, social and economic. The first democratically elected government in 1994 introduced a Black Economic Empowerment (hereafter BEE) strategy to rectify these inequalities. This strategy was accompanied by a BEE Act and the BEE Codes of Good Practice. South African companies subscribed to the BEE strategy for various reasons. A salient fact in all BEE transactions is a discount element presented to the previously disadvantaged investor. This discount element raises the question of whether donations tax arises on these transactions. At first glance, the answer appears straightforward in that no donations tax should arise as this would hinder government’s policy objective of redressing the inequalities of the past. However, there is more to this issue. The purpose of the study on which this article is based was to analyse the overwhelmingly complex BEE structures that have been implemented and to determine the donations tax implications at the various transactional levels. The contribution of this study is that it revealed that tax commentators have taken a simplistic approach to answering the question and that the donations tax implications on the discount element are contentious and unclear. The authors seek to rectify this uncertainty through legislative amendment.
26 February 2024 in South African Journal of Accounting Research
The South African Value-Added Tax (VAT) Act exhibits an illogical structure for digital imports. The complexity of digital import taxation creates uncertainty and has an impact on compliance, resulting in tax avoidance and diminished tax revenues. This study analysed the organisational structure of digital imports in the VAT Act as a legally complex element. This study established that the organisation of the VAT on digital imports complicates legislation and introduces ambiguity, leading to increased tax evasion and compliance, as well as administrative expenses. This study employed existing guidelines to simplify the VAT Act and improve the organisational structure regarding the VAT implications of digital imports. The methods used included a qualitative research technique utilising a doctrinal approach, as well as applied research. This study is the first to apply Hassan, Bornman and Sawyer’s VAT simplification framework to South African digital imports. The guidelines developed by these authors encompass section grouping, headings and subheadings, and explicit signposting, which were implemented in this article to effectively demonstrate and simplify the VAT consequences for digital imports. A logically structured VAT framework will improve clarity in digital import compliance, thereby reducing tax evasion. Therefore, this study contributes to tax compliance theory by proposing that a reduction in complexity and improvement in transparency mitigate tax evasion.
15 March 2026 in South African Journal of Accounting Research
South Africa enacted the Value-Added Tax Act (No. 89 of 1991a) (VAT Act) on 30 September 1991 (Republic of South Africa, 1991a). The VAT Act is based on the consumption method (National Treasury, 2...