As STEM education evolves, educators face growing challenges in selecting and adapting active learning strategies that are pedagogically sound, scalable, and aligned with sustainability goals. This study identifies and analyzes thirteen active (X-BLs) methods using a quantitative and qualitative, multi-criteria framework based on historical originality, conceptual distinctiveness, and compatibility with STEM education. The resulting classification—organized into the categories of originality, innovation, collaboration, and technology—provides a dynamic lens for understanding the development and context of active learning approaches. Beyond its theoretical contribution, the framework offers practical guidance for curriculum designers, school leaders, and policy makers seeking to implement context-sensitive, future-oriented STEM education. By clarifying which methods are foundational and which are more adaptive or emergent, the findings can support strategic decision making, promote pedagogical innovation, and contribute to building more sustainable and interdisciplinary learning environments. This work also sets the stage for further exploration of culturally and regionally grounded pedagogical approaches that address real-world challenges.
This paper investigates how sustainable STEM education is being shaped within the pre-university systems of the 22 Arab countries. By categorizing these systems into four groups based on the Global Knowledge Index and two analytical tracks, this study examines in detail the factors that enable—or hinder—the development of long-term, sustainability-oriented competencies in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. Beyond pedagogical dimensions, this study emphasizes STEM education as a strategic tool for achieving national sustainable development goals (SDGs), promoting workforce readiness, and informing education policy reform. The analysis highlights the policy efforts, systemic limitations, and the need for localized strategies to integrate sustainability into the STEM curricula and teacher training. It is structured in six sections: (1) an introduction to STEM and sustainability concepts, the Global Knowledge Index, and the Arab-region education landscape; (2) research questions, methodology, and data sources; (3) analysis of Groups 1 and 2, assessing their experiences in implementing sustainability-driven STEM initiatives; (4) analysis of Groups 3 and 4, evaluating their readiness for adopting sustainable STEM programs; (5) discussion of findings in light of sustainability policy frameworks; and (6) a concluding overview with actionable recommendations to align national education systems with global sustainability goals.