Partial recirculation can reduce water and fertilizer inputs in indoor strawberry production, but excessive reuse may cause ion-specific nutrient-solution drift. We compared 0%, 30%, and 50% recirculation of gross supplied water in a closed two-tier indoor aeroponic system for ‘Seolhyang’ strawberry over two cultivation years. Each treatment was evaluated as a descriptive operational comparison across the cultivation years, with no independent block-level replication within each cycle. Each recorded run represented directly measured harvest from three internal blocks (480 plants; 25 m2), converted to per-block values (160 plants; 8.33 m2). All the treatments used a stage-adjusted Yamazaki-based nutrient solution, common EC/pH targets, and a gross irrigation supply of 54.0 m3 cycle−1 for the three-block run. Return-water chemistry was analyzed biweekly. Mean yield was 71.7 kg block−1 in the non-recirculating control, 70.0 kg block−1 at 30% recirculation, and 41.7 kg block−1 at 50% recirculation, equivalent to 0.45, 0.44, and 0.26 kg plant−1. Fresh make-up water demand was 18.0, 12.6, and 9.0 m3 block−1 cycle−1, respectively. Increasing reuse depleted P and K; accumulated Ca, Mg, and Na; and narrowed K:Ca and K:(Ca+Mg) ratios. Our results establish 30% recirculation as the threshold that maximizes resource recovery without compromising yield.
Partial nutrient-solution recirculation can improve resource efficiency without establishing net environmental sustainability or private profitability. This secondary bioeconomic assessment used four fixed-layout operational records per setting for 0%, 30%, and 50% recirculation in a Korean two-tier indoor aeroponic strawberry system. Resource indicators were integrated with partial budgeting, 200,000-draw Monte Carlo simulations, downside-risk measures, complementary uncertainty cases, Sobol sensitivity analysis, and capital-recovery and avoided-discharge shadow-value frontiers. Thirty-percent recirculation reduced freshwater make-up by 30.0% and freshwater intensity by 28.3%, while retaining 97.7% of control yield. At the base price and tariff, its incremental margin was −8364 Korean won (KRW), approximately −6.09 United States dollars (USD), per (25/3) m2 block-cycle; parity required 98.54% yield retention. With the observed mean yield difference fixed, the scenario-conditional positive-margin probability was only 2.95%. It was 24.94% under four-record empirical resampling and 55.35% under an exploratory triangular yield envelope, falling to 16.56% when declared labor and energy/consumables burdens were added to that envelope. The triangular result interpolates across sparse, non-independent records and is not a more empirically supported probability estimate. All probabilities assume independent model inputs and retained, incompletely auditable fertilizer-cost allocations. Fifty-percent recirculation remained unfavorable because yield losses outweighed input savings. These findings identify a resource–profitability trade-off, not an environmentally sustainable or optimal recirculation rate; numerical conclusions require independent crop-, facility-, and market-specific evidence.