Boreal forests store are major terrestrial carbon (C) reservoirs, however, the effects of contrasting forest systems on soil microbial composition and functional potential remain poorly understood, particularly in old-growth Caledonian Scots pine woodlands. This study investigated how contrasting forest systems influences soil properties, microbial communities and microbial functional traits in the Cairngorms National Park (Scotland). Fifteen circular plots were established in old-growth Caledonian pinewoods and adjacent Scots pine plantations growing under comparable pedoclimatic conditions. Stand structure, soil respiration, total organic C (TOC), total nitrogen (TN), microbial abundance, bacterial diversity and functional gene involved in C, N, phosphorus (P), and sulphur (S) cycling were assessed using standardized analytical procedures, quantitative (qPCR), and Illumina sequencing. Old-growth forests exhibited higher TOC (~40%) and TN (~1.2%) than plantations, whereas plantations showed higher soil respiration (1.45 g CO2 m-2 h-1). Old-growth soils supported larger bacterial (2.2 109-3.4 109 gene copy n. g soil-1) and fungal (1.7 108-2.2 108 gene copy n. g soil-1) communities and exhibited a more stable microbial organization. In contrast, plantation soils displayed higher spatial heterogeneity, higher relative archaeal abundance, and enrichment of genes associated with nutrient turnover. Across all sites, bacterial communities were dominated by Pseuomonadota, Acidobacteriota, and Actinobacteriota, with plantations favouring disturbance-tolerant taxa and old-growth soils supporting a broader range of specialized low-abundance groups. These finding highlight that forest system strongly influences belowground biodiversity, nutrient cycling, and C dynamics in boreal pine forests. Conserving old-growth Caledonian pinewoods may enhance long-term soil C storage and ecosystem resilience under future climate change.