Efforts to advance science and policy can go hand-in-hand, yet how to achieve both is not always straightforward. One central mechanism for doing so is through translational work and researcher–practitioner partnerships. When done well, they provide opportunities to shed light on important scientific questions and provide a foundation for evidence-based policy. What, though, about situations where the focus of study is politically charged? Here, important scientific questions and policy problems may exist, but it may be difficult to undertake research. These situations amount to “black holes” in research and policy—areas where little is known and where research is especially difficult. In this chapter, we describe the black-hole problem in criminological science and policy. We then argue that translational work and researcher–practitioner partnerships offer a unique opportunity to address these issues, but they may require special or more intensive attention because of the risks and political challenges involved.
The growth of the older adult population, their wealth accumulation, and vulnerabilities from aging have contributed to increasing rates of abuse, fraud, and financial exploitation. However, the current responses and services are fragmented and ineffectual. This paper develops a novel strategy for addressing the variation in response and victim service provision through the development of a problem-solving court that is informed by the principles of restorative justice. Given the unique challenges, cases, and population, a problem-solving court for crimes against older adults will provide tailored interventions, responses, and sanctions while ensuring that older adult victims and their communities are at the center of the criminal justice process and that their needs are prioritized. Research on problem-solving courts; restorative justice; and older adult abuse, fraud, and financial exploitation are integrated with data from a case study of older adult financial exploitation in a large retirement community to develop the model problem-solving court. Consistent with best practices in victim services, the model court will provide comprehensive services in a one-stop location, while simultaneously increasing accountability for offenders who prey on this vulnerable population. The paper concludes with a plan to guide the implementation and evaluation of the proposed model problem-solving court for older adult abuse, fraud, and exploitation.
Translational criminology is the process of using scientific findings to inform criminal justice policy and practice. While seemingly straightforward, the translational process can encounter barriers, including politics, ideology, resource constraints, and causal uncertainty. Despite these challenges, promising practices, including mutually beneficial partnerships and the use of champions, have allowed translational criminology to advance.