We connect two recent advances in the stochastic analysis of nonequilibrium systems: the (loose) uncertainty principle for the currents, which states that statistical errors are bounded by thermodynamic dissipation, and the analysis of thermodynamic consistency of the currents in the light of symmetries. Employing the large deviation techniques presented by Gingrich et al. [ Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 120601 (2016)] and Pietzonka, Barato, and Seifert [ Phys. Rev. E 93, 052145 (2016)], we provide a short proof of the loose uncertainty principle, and prove a tighter uncertainty relation for a class of thermodynamically consistent currents . Our bound involves a measure of partial entropy production, that we interpret as the least amount of entropy that a system sustaining current can possibly produce, at a given steady state. We provide a complete mathematical discussion of quadratic bounds which allows one to determine which are optimal, and finally we argue that the relationship for the Fano factor of the entropy production rate is the most significant realization of the loose bound. We base our analysis both on the formalism of diffusions, and of Markov jump processes in the light of Schnakenberg's cycle analysis.
We derive the statistics of the efficiency under the assumption that thermodynamic fluxes fluctuate with normal law, parametrizing it in terms of time, macroscopic efficiency, and a coupling parameter . It has a peculiar behavior: no moments, one sub-, and one super-Carnot maxima corresponding to reverse operating regimes (engine or pump), the most probable efficiency decreasing in time. The limit where the Carnot bound can be saturated gives rise to two extreme situations, one where the machine works at its macroscopic efficiency, with Carnot limit corresponding to no entropy production, and one where for a transient time scaling like microscopic fluctuations are enhanced in such a way that the most probable efficiency approaches the Carnot limit at finite entropy production.
Thermodynamics is usually formulated on the presumption that the observer has complete information about the system he or she deals with: no parasitic current, exact evaluation of the forces that drive the system. For example, the acclaimed fluctuation relation (FR), relating the probability of time-forward and time-reversed trajectories, assumes that the measurable transitions suffice to characterize the process as Markovian (in our case, a continuous-time jump process). However, most often the observer only measures a marginal current. We show that he or she will nonetheless produce an effective description that does not dispense with the fundamentals of thermodynamics, including the FR and the 2nd law. Our results stand on the mathematical construction of a hidden time reversal of the dynamics, and on the physical requirement that the observed current only accounts for a single transition in the configuration space of the system. We employ a simple abstract example to illustrate our results and to discuss the feasibility of generalizations.
The so-called fluctuation theorems pushed the study of systems far beyond equilibrium, whose response to thermodynamic forces (affinities) is characterized by the reciprocal and the fluctuation-dissipation relations. All these results rely on the assumption that the observer has complete information about the system: no hidden leakage to the environment, exact evaluation of the thermodynamic cost of processes. Will an observer who has marginal information be able to perform an effective thermodynamic analysis? Given that such observer will only be able to establish local equilibrium, by perturbing the stalling currents will he/she observe equilibrium-like fluctuations? Within the formalism of Markov jump processes on finite networks, we provide a broad theory of the statistical behavior of some out of many currents that flow across a system. In particular (1) There exist effective affinities for which an integral fluctuation relation holds; (2) At stalling, i.e. where the marginal currents vanish, a symmetrized fluctuation-dissipation relation holds; (3) Under reasonable assumptions on the parametrization of the rates, effective affinities can be operationally defined by a procedure of tuning to stalling; (4) There exists a notion of marginally time-reversed process which restores the full-fledged fluctuation relation and reciprocity; (5) There exist fluctuation relations across different levels in the hierarchy of more and more “complete” theories. The above results apply to configuration-space currents, and to their phenomenological linear combinations provided certain symmetries of the effective affinities are respected—a condition whose range of validity we deem the most interesting question left open to future inquiry.
We show via counterexamples that relative entropy between the solution of a Markovian master equation and the steady state is not a convex function of time. We thus disprove the hypotheses that a general evolution principle of thermodynamics based on the decrease of the nonadiabatic entropy production could hold. However, we argue that a large separation of typical decay times is necessary for nonconvex solutions to occur, making concave transients extremely short lived with respect to the main relaxation modes. We describe a general method based on the Fisher information matrix to discriminate between generators that admit nonconvex solutions and those that do not. While initial conditions leading to concave transients are shown to be extremely fine-tuned, by our method we are able to select nonconvex initial conditions that are arbitrarily close to the steady state. Convexity does occur when the system is close to satisfying detailed balance or, more generally, when certain normality conditions of the decay modes are satisfied. Our results circumscribe the range of validity of a conjecture by Maes et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 010601 (2011)] regarding monotonicity of the large deviation rate functional for the occupation probability, showing that while the conjecture might hold in the long-time limit, the conditions for Lyapunov's second criterion for stability are not met.