This essay examines emotions as a critical, yet underutilized, dimension in marine conservation and ocean sustainability science. Drawing on cognitive neuroscience, social psychology, human geography, and political ecology, we argue that integrating emotional dimensions into research, policy, and practice can enhance both understanding and action toward marine conservation and ocean sustainability. We conceptualize emotions, and explore their experiential and functional implications in marine contexts. Using targeted case examples and theories, we identify both opportunities and challenges for applying emotional insights in research, policy, and practice, including barriers posed by dominant rationality models of human decision-making. We present intellectual pathways as well as research, methodological and policy agendas to integrate emotions into marine conservation research and strategies. Our analysis responds to gaps in the literature and provides actionable recommendations for researchers, policymakers, and practitioners during the UN Decade of Ocean Science for Sustainable Development.
Common property research has long situated itself at the intersection of evidence-based research and advocacy that seeks to empower communities through local or collaborative governance of shared resources. While these identities often converge to provide a strong rationale for considering common property governance, they can sometimes diverge and raise important questions concerning our ability to satisfy our ethical obligations to local communities, external policymakers and the research community. Efforts to support community empowerment through close engagement in research may, for instance, bias the results and influence our ability to satisfy our ethical obligations to external stakeholders and the research community. In contrast, exclusion of communities can result in inaccurate or incomplete evidence about the commons that can serve to undermine our ethical obligations to all three groups and potentially contribute to the marginalization of communities. Although these tensions have long existed, they can no longer be ignored by common property researchers who must instead carefully examine the ethical implications of their approach to developing, undertaking and sharing the results of their research. In this chapter we draw upon our own experiences to identify consensus and contested standards for satisfying our ethical obligations to three core groups, including the communities that contribute to and inform our studies, the external stakeholders that may develop policies and programs on the basis of our research and the broader research community. In so doing we further identify areas of healthy dispute that illuminate our deep engagement with implementing best practices and good intentions.