Rachel Gimson

Dr. Rachel Gimson


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

8Years (2019-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
28 October 2019 in Legal Studies
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
RGRachel Gimson
Rachel Gimson
Contemporary criminal justice is premised on a rights-bearing defendant safe-guarded by due process from arbitrary state punishment. The paucity of academic commentary on the role of the criminal defendant suggests that there is a common assumption that the role is static. However, the rights-bearing defendant is a relatively new concept. Through a legal history analysis, this paper demonstrates that the defendant's role can mutate in response to pressures placed on the criminal trial. Broadly, there have been three conceptualisations of the defendant: the penitent Anglo-Norman defendant; the advocate defendant of the jury trial; and the rights-bearing adversarial defendant. Importantly, the shift from one conceptualisation to another has occurred gradually, often without commentary or conscious effort to instigate change. There are many contemporary pressures that could be impacting on the rights-bearing defendant. The concept of a mutable defendant provides a new theory through which to analyse these pressures. This paper considers the introduction of adverse inferences regarding the right to silence and disclosure, and the rise of ‘digilantism’. These new pressures, it is suggested, help to facilitate a rhetoric of deservingness that goes against the rights-bearing defendant and raises the risk its role could once again be mutating.

16 June 2025 in Social Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SOSiobhan O'Dwyer
Siobhan O'Dwyer
CBCharlotte Bishop
Charlotte Bishop
RGRachel Gimson
Rachel Gimson
GMG. J. Melendez-Torres
G. J. Melendez-Torres
DSDaniel Stevens
Daniel Stevens
LHLorna Hardy
Lorna Hardy
In the news media, there are regular reports of family caregivers killing the people for whom they care, but scholarly research on this phenomenon is fragmented, and there has been little effort to predict or prevent future deaths. The aim of this study was to develop a typology of caregiver-perpetrated homicides that could provide a framework for more rigorous research and targeted responses in policy and practice. Ideal Type Analysis was applied to sixty-four homicides and homicide–suicides perpetrated by family caregivers in England and Wales between January 2015 and December 2019. The cases clustered into seven clear types: Ending Suffering; Genuine Burden of Care; Pre-existing Mental Illness; Neglect; Exploitation; Caregiver as Victim of Domestic Violence, Abuse or Coercive Control; and Caregiver as Perpetrator of Domestic Violence, Abuse, or Coercive Control. Each type was characterised by a distinct motive, context, or course of events leading to the homicide. This is the first typology of homicides and homicide–suicides perpetrated by caregivers. The Caregiver-Perpetrated Homicide Typology challenges previous claims that caregiver-perpetrated homicides are isolated events and provides a framework for the development of evidence-based prediction and prevention initiatives.

6 November 2026 in The Journal of Criminal Law
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
RGRachel Gimson
Rachel Gimson
The courts in England and Wales have long broadened the scope of the partial defences to include ‘mercy’ killers, particularly to avoid the mandatory life sentence. The 2009 reforms tightened the partial defences, creating an assumption that ‘mercy’ killers were excluded. Homicides perpetrated by unpaid carers are often described as ‘mercy’ killings. Drawing on empirical research that constructed a typology of such killings, this article demonstrates that not all carer-perpetrated homicides are ‘mercy’ killings. The data also suggests there is still a judicial willingness to broadly interpret the partial defences to include cases they label as acts of ‘mercy’. Questions must therefore be asked if this is, to quote Buxton LJ, once again a ‘smuggling in of mercy’. Either the interpretation of the partial defences needs to be stricter, or reform is needed to better reflect what is happening at trial.