The factors underlying the ‘zoo visit effect’ (changes in animal behaviour/physiology in response to visitor presence) are still poorly understood, despite it being widely investigated. The present study examined the effect of zoo visitors on the behaviour of 17 different species of mammals at the Belo Horizonte Zoo, Minas Gerais, Brazil. The behaviour of the animals was recorded using scan (focal in one case) sampling with instantaneous recording of behaviour, during 12 continuous months. Data were analysed using a comparative method examining five different factors: diet, body weight, stratum occupied, activity cycle, and habitat, as well as three different visitor categories: small and quiet audience, medium size audience and medium noise, and large size and loud audience. Significant changes in the behaviour for each factor, especially increases in locomotor and resting behaviour, were observed in response to different visitor categories. The factors that most explained responses to visitor categories were habitat and activity cycle. Species from closed habitats compared to open habitats were significantly more impacted (more behaviour affected), probably, because they are, evolutionarily, less accustomed to visual contact with people. Diurnal species showed more behavioural changes than nocturnal ones, possibly, because they were being observed during their normal activity cycle. These results may help zoos identify which mammal species are most susceptible to the zoo visitor effect, and consequently, be more pro-active in the use of mitigating strategies.
Anthropogenic noise has been related to stress in captive animals; despite this there have been few studies on animal welfare assessment in walk-through zoo enclosures. We aimed to investigate the behavioural effects of noise on a male-female pair of two-toed sloths (Choloepus didactylus), housed in a walk-through enclosure in a zoo in the UK. The animals were filmed for 24 h per day, during three days per week, including days with potential low and high flow of visitors, for three weeks. Sound pressure measurement was performed four times each collection day (twice in the morning, once at noon and once in the afternoon), for 15 min per session, using a sound level meter. The number of visitors passing the enclosure during each session was also recorded. The videos were analysed using focal sampling, with continuous recording of behaviour. Correlations between noise and the behaviours expressed during, and in the 24 h after the acoustic recording, were investigated. The number of visitors correlated with the acoustic parameters. At the moment of exposure, higher levels of noise correlated with decreased inactivity, and longer expression of locomotion and maintenance behaviours for the male; the female spent more time inside a box in these moments. During the 24 h hours after exposure to loud noise, the female showed no behavioural changes while the male tended to reduce foraging. The behavioural changes observed in both individuals have already been reported in other species, in response to stressful events. Our study indicates the need for a good acoustic management in walk-through zoo enclosures where sloths are housed.
Zoos are increasingly hosting out-of-hours events such as ‘Music Nights’ to increase visitation, raising potential animal welfare concerns due to anthropogenic noise pollution. This study examined the physiological stress response, measured through faecal glucocorticoid metabolite (FGCM), of Bornean orangutans (Pongo pygmaeus; n = 6) at Twycross Zoo during four consecutive weekends of live music events. Faecal samples were collected over these weekends and compared with a comprehensive 24 h acoustic analysis of the enclosure. The acoustic data indicated that the environment was dominated by noise from the ventilation system, which masked the sound from the live music. Comparisons of acoustic metrics between Event and Non-Event periods showed that LAeq, LA10, and LA90 were significantly higher during event hours or open zoo periods. In contrast, daily means did not differ. Group-averaged FGCM concentrations were higher on Event days (mean ± SE: Event = 826 ± 99 ng/g; No Event = 701 ± 44 ng/g), but comparisons for each individual showed no significant differences (Batu: t = 0.577, p = 0.596; Maliku: t = 1.475, p = 0.212; Molly: t = 0.290, p = 0.786; Kibriah: t = 0.771, p = 0.506). In contrast, FGCM concentrations increased significantly with increasing acoustic levels (LAeq) across individuals, with Batu and Maliku generally showing higher FGCM levels in response to louder days. These findings suggest that the constant background noise may have caused partial habituation. At the same time, individual variation highlights the importance of assessing physiological responses at the individual level, as relying on group-level data may overlook adverse welfare effects on sensitive individuals.