The Galápagos Petrel (Pterodroma phaeopygia) is a long-lived Critically Endangered seabird endemic to the Galápagos Islands and faces severe threats from invasive species, particularly rodents. Until now, evidence of rat predation on Galápagos Petrel nestlings has been largely indirect, inferred from indirect evidence and predator control outcomes. Here, we present the first photographic documentation of a presumed black rat (Rattus rattus) preying on a Galápagos Petrel nestling, captured by a camera trap on private farmland on Santa Cruz Island. The predation event occurred during a period of parental absence, when the nestling was left unattended while adults foraged at sea. Notably, the parent Petrels continued returning to the nest for 91 days following nestling loss, suggesting strong nest fidelity and highlighting potential energetic costs associated with breeding failure. Our findings reveal critical vulnerabilities during the nestling-rearing phase and emphasize the urgent need to enhance rodent control efforts and protect nesting areas, particularly on farmland outside the Galápagos National Park boundaries. We conclude by providing targeted conservation recommendations to mitigate invasive predator impacts and improve breeding success for this emblematic and imperiled seabird.