Peer-feedback can be an effective method to support learning. However, students often require instructional support to provide and process peer-feedback effectively. Previous research used various types of instructional support to improve the quality of peer-feedback processes and outcomes. Yet, a comprehensive overview over their effects is missing. Therefore, this meta-analysis (based on N = 32 studies with N = 3806 learners) investigates the effects of different kinds of instructional support (feedback provision vs. feedback reception; content-specific vs. generic) on peer-feedback processes (formulating high-quality feedback messages, or effectively reflecting on the feedback received) and outcomes (subject-matter-related knowledge). Overall, peer-feedback with vs. without instructional support had a substantial positive effect (g = 0.47). Furthermore, we found a positive effect of feedback provision support on the quality of feedback provision (g = 0.72) and the quality of feedback reception (g = 0.69) but not on subject-matter-related knowledge. For feedback reception support, we found no effects on peer-feedback processes and outcomes at all. During feedback provision, content-specific support positively influenced the quality of feedback provision (g = 0.75) but not subject-matter-related knowledge, while generic support exerts a positive impact on the quality of feedback provision (g = 0.70) and subject-matter-related knowledge (g = 0.55). During feedback reception, we again found no significant effects of content-related support and generic support at all. The lack of effects for feedback reception support may be related to the limited number of studies on feedback reception in general. Finally, concrete implications and suggestions for future research are provided.
Prior research has explored various factors to explain differences in teaching experiences and behaviors among school teachers, including self-efficacy, basic psychological need satisfaction, and emotions. However, these factors have predominantly been examined in isolation, and limited research has investigated their role in the context of higher education teaching. To address these research gaps, analyses on both the within and between teacher level are needed. The aim of the present study was therefore to investigate the interplay between these motivational and emotional constructs on both levels, as well as the relevance and applicability of prior research findings on school teachers to the context of higher education teaching at universities. In a micro-longitudinal study, 103 university teachers from Germany (49 female; average age: 41.4 years, SD = 11.0) completed assessments of their self-efficacy in 748 sessions directly before their teaching sessions, as well as their basic psychological need satisfaction and discrete emotions directly after. Multilevel structural equation modeling revealed positive associations between self-efficacy and basic psychological need satisfaction. Self-efficacy was negatively associated with negative emotions, and positive indirect effects on positive emotions as well as negative indirect effects on negative emotions were identified through satisfaction of the needs for competence and relatedness. Basic psychological need satisfaction was positively related to positive emotions and vice versa—however, unexpected positive associations between relatedness and negative emotions emerged and require further research.
Integrating sustainability into school curricula is increasingly important, with teachers seen as key “change agents”. However, many lack specific preparation for Education for Sustainable Development (ESD), and there is considerable variability in how explicitly or implicitly they address these topics in their teaching. The purpose of this study was to investigate interpersonal and contextual factors related to ESD implementation, including self- and action-efficacy, personal attitudes, eco-anxiety, private engagement and knowledge, alongside perceived student interest and pressure, and school awareness. A total of 419 teachers from various German primary and secondary schools (M = 45 years, SD = 10.9; 68% female; teaching experience: M = 16 years, SD = 9.9) completed a cross-sectional online survey and knowledge test. Findings showed significant variation in how often teachers included sustainability in their teaching, unrelated to gender, school type, or training. Network analyses revealed that self-efficacy and private engagement—rather than teachers’ knowledge—were central predictors of ESD integration. Notably, private engagement emerged as a key bridge in the network, while high self-efficacy was closely tied to frequent classroom implementation. These results suggest that fostering teachers’ personal commitment and confidence may be more effective than focusing solely on knowledge to promote sustainability education.
Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung (BNE) ist ein Schlüsselkonzept für die Zukunftsfähigkeit unserer Gesellschaft. In der Schule sind Lehrkräfte die wichtigsten Akteure für die Umsetzung von BNE. Nur wenn die Unterrichtenden sich in der Lage fühlen, etwas zu beeinflussen (Selbstwirksamkeitserwartung), werden sie die Integration von Nachhaltigkeit im Bildungssystem mittragen und weiterbringen. Voraussetzungen dafür sind förderliche Strukturen (etwa Zeit, Freiräume, Materialien, Weiterbildung) und emotionaler Halt (etwa Unterstützung, Konfliktfähigkeit).