Objective: Evaluate usability and utility of National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) Patient Decision Aid's (PtDA's) for pelvic floor surgery. PtDA's reviewed were uterine prolapse, vault prolapse and stress urinary incontinence (SUI).Design: Ten women given the PtDA's during routine clinical care were recruited from each cohort and underwent a semi‐structured interview with a clinical researcher.Setting: Urogynaecology outpatients in an NHS tertiary teaching hospital.Population or Sample: Women considering surgical management of uterine/vault prolapse or SUI. Exclusion criteria included those under 18, unable to communicate in English or not eligible for all surgical options discussed in the PtDA's.Methods: A qualitative, semi‐structured interview evaluating women's opinions of the decision aid and the way in which they utilised the PtDA was conducted. The interviews were recorded and transcribed prior to undertaking thematic analysis utilising NVivo software.Main Outcome Measure: The outcomes of interest were feedback for content, language, format and usage of the PtDA's and women's usage of PtDA's in decision‐making.Results: Amendments suggested included removal of mesh from the SUI PtDA as this is not routinely available on the NHS and addition of a statement regarding the use of mesh in prolapse surgery. Additional anatomical diagrams were suggested. The need for a robust and regular update system was highlighted as was the provision of foreign language, audio and electronic versions.Conclusions: PtDA's need updating to ensure relevant content. Clear, detailed and relevant information is required alongside active clinician engagement to reach a mutually agreeable treatment plan.
28 July 2025 in BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology
Objectives: To evaluate whether the use of a patient decision aid (PDA) diminishes decision conflict in patients considering surgical treatment for stress urinary incontinence (SUI) or pelvic organ prolapse (POP) and to assess patient satisfaction concerning the PDA's user‐friendliness and overall utility.Design: One hundred women attending routine urogynaecology clinic appointments were offered the PDA as part of standard care and recruited into the study. After using the PDA, participants completed a decisional conflict scale (DCS) to assess their decision‐making experience.Setting: Single‐site NHS tertiary‐level care hospital outpatient department.Population and Sample: The study included women considering surgical management for uterine/vault prolapse or SUI. Exclusion criteria comprised individuals under 18 years of age, those unable to communicate in English and patients not eligible for all surgical options presented in the PDAs.Methods: Patients presenting to the urogynaecology clinic with symptomatic SUI or POP considering surgical treatment were invited to participate in the study. After using the PDA and at their next clinic visit, participants completed a DCS to assess their decision‐making experience.Main Outcome Measure: The DCS assessed the level of uncertainty and difficulty participants experienced in deciding on surgical treatment after using the PDA. A DCS score of less than 25 was associated with certainty in implementing the decision.Results: This was a prospective cohort study of 100 participants. The DCS scores for the cohorts showed low decisional conflict, with median scores of 0.8 (IQR 4.7) for the vault PDA, 6.3 (IQR 25) for the uterine PDA and 7.8 (IQR 21.1) for the SUI PDA. A sub‐score analysis revealed higher scores for ‘uncertainty’ and ‘effective decision making’ in 21 participants with total DCS scores above 25.Conclusion: NICE PDAs are valuable tools for enhancing decision‐making in gynaecological surgery. However, this study highlights the need for their ongoing refinement to better address the informational and emotional aspects of patient decision‐making. Future research should focus on incorporating emotional support frameworks and psychological management tools to improve their clinical utility and effectiveness.
5 September 2024 in International Urogynecology Journal
Background/Objectives: Pelvic organ prolapse (POP) is a common condition that significantly impacts quality of life. Research has focused largely on older women, while experiences of younger women remain relatively underexplored despite challenges unique to this population. Informed by the biopsychosocial model of illness, this study aims to assess the symptom burden, treatment goals, and information needs of younger women complaining of prolapse by analyzing questionnaire responses from an existing electronic Personal Assessment Questionnaire—Pelvic Floor (ePAQ-PF) dataset. Methods: Mixed-methods content analysis was conducted using free-text data from an anonymized multi-site ePAQ-PF dataset of 5717 responses collected across eight UK NHS trusts (2018–2022). A quantitative, deductive approach was first used to identify younger women (≤50 years old) with self-reported prolapse. ePAQ-PF scores for younger women with prolapse were compared with those aged >50 years, using Mann–Whitney tests. Free-text response data were analyzed inductively to qualitatively explore younger women’s symptom burden, treatment goals, and information needs. Results: Of the 1473 women with prolapse identified, 399 were aged ≤50 years. ePAQ-PF scores of the younger cohort demonstrated significantly greater symptom severity and bother than those aged >50, particularly in bowel, prolapse, vaginal, body image, and sexual health domains (p < adjusted threshold). Qualitative analysis undertaken to understand women’s concerns and priorities produced five health-related themes (physical health; functionality; psychosocial and emotional wellbeing; reproductive and sexual health; and healthcare journeys) and a sixth intersecting theme representing information needs. Conclusions: The findings highlight the substantial symptom burden of younger women with prolapse, as well as treatment goals and information needs specific to this population. The development of age-specific resources is identified as a requirement to support this group.