About 40% of all health burden in New Zealand is due to cancer, cardiovascular disease, and type 2 diabetes/obesity. Outcomes for Māori (indigenous people) are significantly worse than non-Maori; these inequities mirror those found in indigenous communities elsewhere. Evidence-based interventions with established efficacy may not be effective in indigenous communities without addressing specific implementation challenges. We present an implementation framework for interventions to prevent and treat chronic conditions for Māori and other indigenous communities. The He Pikinga Waiora Implementation Framework has indigenous self-determination at its core and consists of four elements: cultural-centeredness, community engagement, systems thinking, and integrated knowledge translation. All elements have conceptual fit with Kaupapa Māori aspirations (i.e., indigenous knowledge creation, theorizing, and methodology) and all have demonstrated evidence of positive implementation outcomes. A coding scheme derived from the Framework was applied to 13 studies of diabetes prevention in indigenous communities in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United States from a systematic review. Cross-tabulations demonstrated that culture-centeredness (p = .008) and community engagement (p = .009) explained differences in diabetes outcomes and community engagement (p = .098) explained difference in blood pressure outcomes. The He Pikinga Waiora Implementation Framework appears to be well suited to advance implementation science for indigenous communities in general and Māori in particular. The framework has promise as a policy and planning tool to evaluate and design effective interventions for chronic disease prevention in indigenous communities.
Purpose: This study aims to understand the engagement between an indigenous social service provider and marginalised clients deemed “hard-to-reach” to gain an insight into how to improve the client’s engagement and well-being through transformative value co-creation. Design/methodology/approach: The exploratory study’s findings draw on primary data employing a qualitative research approach through document analysis and in-depth interviews with clients, social workers and stakeholders of the focal social service provider in New Zealand. Findings: The findings indicate that there are inhibitors and enablers of value or well-being co-creation. The lack of client resources and a mismatch between client and social worker are primary barriers. Other actors as well as cultural practices are identified as enablers of well-being improvement. Research limitations/implications: This research reports on a single social service provider and its clients. These findings may not be readily transferrable to other contexts. Practical implications: Findings indicate that social service providers require a heightened awareness of the inhibitors and enablers of social service co-creation. Social implications: Both the integrative framework and the findings provide a sound critique of the prevailing policy discourse surrounding the stigmatisation of members of society deemed “hard-to-reach” and the usefulness of such an approach when aiming at resolving social issues. Originality/value: This is the first exploratory study that reports on the engagement between a social service provider and its clients in a dedicated Māori (indigenous) context by employing an integrative research approach combining transformative service research, activity theory and engagement theory.
1 May 2007 in Journal of the Operational Research Society
While lean thinking has been used in healthcare for almost two decades, its efficacy has been debated extensively by researchers and practitioners alike. This ongoing debate is largely due to the varied results of its implementation; and resistance to change is considered to be the primary reason behind this variation. This study adopts an institutional logics perspective to analyze the nature of this resistance by drawing attention to how clinical staff make judgements about the appropriateness, acceptability and legitimacy of lean thinking. To conceptualize resistance, a systematic literature review based on 33 published studies depicting lean implementations was conducted, which helped to develop a nuanced understanding of resistance and its causes. Subsequently, 47 semi-structured interviews were undertaken with Quality Improvement managers regarding their experience with implementing lean thinking in 15 New Zealand District Health Boards. These interviews were used to identify and evaluate strategies used to minimize resistance within the implementation of lean initiatives in healthcare organizations. The findings of this research suggest that typically there are three strategies adopted by quality improvement managers—(1) communication strategies to create a better narrative for lean implementation; (2) cooperation strategies, which encourage the adherents of lean and medical logics to work together on shared problems, creating opportunities for them to learn about other logics; and (3) performance management strategies with the help of incentives and commitment devices to create a supportive environment for lean implementation. Together, these strategies work to improve the availability, accessibility, and activation of lean thinking logic in healthcare.