Rose Eerdmans

Ms. Rose Eerdmans

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

4Years (2023-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 February 2023 in Law and Human Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JSJessica M. Salerno
Jessica M. Salerno
KKKylie Kulak
Kylie Kulak
LSLaura Smalarz
Laura Smalarz
RERose Eerdmans
Rose Eerdmans
MLMegan Lawrence
Megan Lawrence
TDTramanh Dao
Tramanh Dao
Recently, experimental work on racial bias in legal settings has diverged from real-world field data demonstrating racial disparities, instead often producing null or potential overcorrection effects favoring Black individuals over White individuals. We explored the role of social desirability in these counterintuitive effects and tested whether allowing participants to establish nonracist moral credentials increased their willingness to convict a Black defendant. We predicted that establishing nonracist moral credentials would increase convictions of Black defendants-especially for participants likely to harbor racial bias and external motivation to control it. In two experiments, we randomly assigned White mock jurors (Study 1: N = 1,018; Study 2: N = 1,253) to establish nonracist moral credentials by acquitting a Black defendant in an initial case, acquit a White defendant in the same case, or see no prior case. Next, they judged an ambiguous case against a Black (Studies 1 and 2) or White (Study 2) defendant. After choosing verdicts, they provided open-ended guesses of what the study was about. Participants completed measures of explicit prejudice, motivations to control prejudice, and political orientation. Most participants who were asked to judge at least one Black defendant guessed that the study was about racial bias and convicted Black defendants less often than did those who guessed the study was about something else. White participants who established nonracist credentials were significantly more likely to convict Black defendants compared with White participants who did not establish nonracist credentials. Subsequent analyses revealed that conservatives showed this predicted credentialing pattern, whereas liberals did not. Credentialed liberals' convictions of Black defendants remained low; instead, they convicted White defendants more than did noncredentialed liberals. Social desirability plays a clear role in whether White people acquit Black defendants in experiments, which does not align with persistent racial bias in the legal system. Research participants' concern about looking prejudiced might undermine the validity of experiments investigating racial bias in legal settings by artificially inflating pro-Black judgments. The opportunity to credential oneself as nonracist, however, might make conservatives more comfortable making anti-Black legal judgments-whereas credentialed liberals continue to judge Black individuals more favorably than White individuals in legal settings. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).

1 February 2023 in Law and Human Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
LSLaura Smalarz
Laura Smalarz
RERose Eerdmans
Rose Eerdmans
MLMegan Lawrence
Megan Lawrence
KKKylie Kulak
Kylie Kulak
JSJessica M. Salerno
Jessica M. Salerno
Despite documented racial disparities in all facets of the criminal justice system, recent laboratory attempts to investigate racial bias in legal settings have produced null effects or racial-bias reversals. These counterintuitive findings may be an artifact of laboratory participants' attempts to appear unprejudiced in response to social norms that proscribe expressions of racial bias against Black individuals. Furthermore, given pervasive stereotypes linking Black people with crime and heightened attention to issues of racial injustice in the legal system, laboratory participants may be especially likely to attempt to appear unprejudiced in studies examining judgments of Black individuals in legal as opposed to nonlegal contexts. We predicted that counterintuitive race effects (null and pro-Black effects) are more likely to occur in laboratory research examining race in legal than in nonlegal contexts. We conducted a quantitative review of race effects in three leading social psychology and legal psychology journals over the last four decades (Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin [PSPB]; Law and Human Behavior [LHB]; Psychology, Public Policy, and Law [PPPL]). We then conducted two experiments in which students (N = 314; Experiment 1) and Mechanical Turk workers (N = 695; Experiment 2) read descriptions of White and Black targets in either legal or nonlegal contexts and rated each target along various characteristics (e.g., dangerous, trustworthy). Our analysis of the literature indicated that counterintuitive race effects were more frequent in studies examining race in legal compared with nonlegal contexts. Our experiments likewise revealed that pro-Black race effects were stronger in legal than in nonlegal contexts. Laboratory research on racial bias against Black people-especially in legal settings-may produce misleading conclusions about the effects of race on important real-world outcomes. Methodological innovations for studying racial bias are needed. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).

1 October 2024 in Law and Human Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MLMegan Lawrence
Megan Lawrence
ESEmma R. Saiter
Emma R. Saiter
RERose Eerdmans
Rose Eerdmans
LSLaura Smalarz
Laura Smalarz
Despite the risks inherent to custodial police interrogation, criminal suspects may waive their Miranda rights and submit to police questioning in fear that exercising their rights or remaining silent will make them appear guilty. We tested whether such a Miranda penalty exists. We predicted that people would perceive suspects who invoke their Miranda rights or sit in silence during an interrogation as more likely to be guilty than those who waive their Miranda rights. In two experiments, undergraduate psychology students (Experiment 1; N = 256) and students enrolled in law-enforcement-related degree programs (Experiment 2; N = 119) were instructed to play the role of a police officer investigating a series of crimes in which the suspect invoked his Miranda rights, sat in silence, or spoke to police. Participants evaluated each suspect along various characteristics (e.g., honest, suspicious), assessed his likely guilt, and reported how many hours they would allocate to investigating the suspect versus other potential suspects. Suspects who invoked their right to silence or remained silent, compared with those who waived their rights and spoke to police, were perceived more negatively and judged as guiltier. Participants also allocated more hours toward investigating such suspects. The protective power of Miranda is eroded by the tendency for people to infer guilt from a suspect's decision to invoke Miranda or remain silent during police interrogation. This Miranda penalty violates suspects' legal protection from being penalized for exercising their constitutional rights against self-incrimination and may bias the investigation and prosecution of criminal suspects. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).

17 September 2025 in Behavioral Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MLMegan Lawrence
Megan Lawrence
KGKristen Gittings
Kristen Gittings
STSara Nicole Thomas
Sara Nicole Thomas
RERose Eerdmans
Rose Eerdmans
VHValerie Hans
Valerie Hans
JSJessica M Salerno
Jessica M Salerno
Objective: U.S. courts have implemented interventions educating jurors about implicit bias, although evidence for their effectiveness remains limited. We explored public perceptions of these interventions that might influence their ability to improve trial fairness and identified psychological factors predicting such perceptions. Hypotheses: We hypothesized that certain psychological factors (i.e., political conservatism, psychological reactance, skepticism toward social scientists, implicit and explicit racial bias, advantaged-group identity management strategies) would predict support for implicit bias interventions in courts. Method: White participants (N = 1016)—some of whom watched an implicit bias intervention in one of two formats (educational video, judicial instructions)—provided their perceptions of implicit bias interventions, evaluated the intervention they watched (if applicable), and completed individual difference measures. Results: Overall, participants supported implicit bias interventions in both formats. However, political conservatism and other hypothesized individual difference measures were associated with less favorable perceptions. We further explored participants’ perspectives via a thematic content analysis of open-ended impressions of the interventions. Conclusions: Courts are adopting implicit bias interventions despite mixed research regarding their effectiveness and a limited understanding of how they are perceived. Our findings suggest that White participants generally favor these interventions and offer insight into the nuances of their perceptions.

1 May 2026 in Psychology, Public Policy, and Law
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
RERose Eerdmans
Rose Eerdmans
LSLaura Smalarz
Laura Smalarz

27 November 2023 in PsyArXiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
HPHannah Phalen
Hannah Phalen
MLMegan Lawrence
Megan Lawrence
KGKristen Gittings
Kristen Gittings
RERose Eerdmans
Rose Eerdmans
STSara Thomas
Sara Thomas
JSJessica Salerno
Jessica Salerno
Objective: There are documented gender disparities in the legal field. We examined whether gender representation on civil trial teams varied on the basis of (a) the degree of regional gender bias “in the air” and (b) time. Hypotheses: We hypothesized that women were underrepresented both on trial teams and in leadership roles within those teams. We predicted that these gender disparities were exacerbated in regions with stronger regional gender bias and that these gender disparities attenuated over time. Method: We coded attorney gender and case outcomes in real civil trials (N = 655). We created regional implicit and explicit gender bias scores based on the year and region of the case using Project Implicit data. Finally, we used order-constrained inference and Bayesian modeling to identify the best-performing models. Results: Overall, women represented only 17% of attorneys at trial and 13% in leadership roles—indicating vast gender disparities. Gender disparities on teams and in leadership roles were more extreme in regions with high (vs. low) regional gender bias (teams: Bayes factor [BF] = 9,182; leadership: BF = 91,667) and improved over time (teams: BF = 6,420; leadership: BF = 3,495). Gender alone best predicted the likelihood of serving in a leadership role (BF = 1,197,397). Conclusion: Female attorneys were grossly underrepresented on civil trial teams. Gender representation on teams, but not leadership roles, has improved slightly over time. Culture may also contribute; women were less represented on trial teams in regions with greater gender bias in the air—particularly in leadership roles. Despite these slight improvements in representation on trial teams over time and in low-bias regions, gender disparities in leadership roles persist over time and levels of regional bias.