Cosmic‐ray neutron sensors (CRNS) fill the gap between locally measured in‐situ soil moisture (SM) and remotely sensed SM by providing accurate SM estimation at the field scale. This is promising for improving hydrologic model predictions, as CRNS can provide valuable information on SM in the root zone at the typical scale of a model grid cell. In this study, SM measurements from a network of 12 CRNS in the Rur catchment (Germany) were assimilated into the Terrestrial System Modeling Platform (TSMP) to investigate its potential for improving SM, evapotranspiration (ET) and river discharge characterization and estimating soil hydraulic parameters at the larger catchment scale. The data assimilation (DA) experiments (with and without parameter estimation) were conducted in both a wet year (2016) and a dry year (2018) with the ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF), and later verified with an independent year (2017) without DA. The results show that SM characterization was significantly improved at measurement locations (with up to 60% root mean square error (RMSE) reduction), and that joint state‐parameter estimation improved SM simulation more than state estimation alone (more than 15% additional RMSE reduction). Jackknife experiments showed that SM at verification locations had lower and different improvements in the wet and dry years (an RMSE reduction of 40% in 2016 and 16% in 2018). In addition, SM assimilation was found to improve ET characterization to a much lesser extent, with a 15% RMSE reduction of monthly ET in the wet year and 9% in the dry year.
Land surface modeling combined with data assimilation can yield highly accurate soil moisture estimates on regional and global scales. However, most land surface models often neglect lateral surface and subsurface flows, which are crucial for water redistribution and soil moisture. This study applies the Community Land Model (CLM) and the coupled CLM‐ParFlow model over a 22,500 area in western Germany. Soil moisture retrievals from the Soil Moisture Active Passive mission are assimilated with the Localized Ensemble Kalman Filter (with and without parameter estimation). The simulated soil moisture, evapotranspiration (ET) and groundwater level are evaluated using in situ observations from a Cosmic‐Ray Neutron Sensor network, Eddy Covariance (EC) stations and groundwater measurement wells. The assimilation improves the median correlation between simulated and measured soil moisture from 0.72 0.79 to 0.79 0.83 and decreases the median unbiased Root Mean Square Error (ubRMSE) from 0.063 0.060 / to 0.050 0.045 /. ET characterization shows a limited improvement with a highest ubRMSE reduction of 15% at the Rollesbroich1 site with the CLM‐ParFlow model. The assimilation does not improve the groundwater level characterization. Furthermore, the joint state‐parameter update does not outperform state‐only update. Overall, the simulation of full 3D subsurface hydrology with the ParFlow model component results in additional model outputs like groundwater levels and river stages, and a better soil moisture characterization (compared to CLM stand‐alone), but it does not make soil moisture assimilation more efficient to correct model states.
18 November 2025 in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
Uncertainties in hydrological simulations can be quantified and reduced through data assimilation (DA). This study explores strategies for assimilating soil moisture (SM) data from Cosmic-Ray Neutron Sensors (CRNS) and groundwater level (GWL) data into the Terrestrial System Modeling Platform (TSMP), which integrates both land surface and subsurface processes. DA experiments incorporating both state and parameter estimation were performed using the localized Ensemble Kalman Filter (LEnKF) within a representative catchment in Germany over the period 2016 to 2018, with cross-validation conducted on non-overlapping years. Univariate assimilation of SM reduced the unbiased root mean square error (ubRMSE) by approximately 50 %, while univariate assimilation of GWL achieved up to a 70 % reduction in ubRMSE at assimilation sites. Improvements in GWL estimates extended up to 5 km from the assimilation points, with ubRMSE reductions ranging between 2 % and 50 %. However, assimilating GWL independently had a negative effect on SM representation, and similarly, assimilating SM alone degraded GWL predictions. To address these issues, a novel multivariate DA framework was developed, enabling SM and GWL to be assimilated independently through separate modules. Groundwater data were used to constrain the water table position, thereby improving the estimation of the boundary between unsaturated and saturated zones and allowing updates to hydraulic conditions within the saturated zone. Meanwhile, SM data improved the representation of hydrological processes in the unsaturated zone. The multivariate assimilation approach resulted in comparable improvements in GWL, SM, and evapotranspiration (ET) at the assimilation sites. Moreover, including parameter estimation alongside state updating further reduced the ubRMSE by up to 17 %.
Uncertainties in hydrological simulations can be quantified and reduced through data assimilation (DA). This study explores strategies for assimilating soil moisture (SM) data from Cosmic-Ray Neutron Sensors (CRNS) and groundwater level (GWL) data into the Terrestrial System Modeling Platform (TSMP), which integrates both land surface and subsurface processes. DA experiments incorporating both state and parameter estimation were performed using the localized Ensemble Kalman Filter (LEnKF) within a representative catchment in Germany over the period 2016 to 2018, with cross-validation conducted on non-overlapping years. Univariate assimilation of SM reduced the unbiased root mean square error (ubRMSE) by approximately 50 %, while univariate assimilation of GWL achieved up to a 70 % reduction in ubRMSE at assimilation sites. Improvements in GWL estimates extended up to 5 km from the assimilation points, with ubRMSE reductions ranging between 2 % and 50 %. However, assimilating GWL independently had a negative effect on SM representation, and similarly, assimilating SM alone degraded GWL predictions. To address these issues, a novel multivariate DA framework was developed, enabling SM and GWL to be assimilated independently through separate modules. Groundwater data were used to constrain the water table position, thereby improving the estimation of the boundary between unsaturated and saturated zones and allowing updates to hydraulic conditions within the saturated zone. Meanwhile, SM data improved the representation of hydrological processes in the unsaturated zone. The multivariate assimilation approach resulted in comparable improvements in GWL, SM, and evapotranspiration (ET) at the assimilation sites. Moreover, including parameter estimation alongside state updating further reduced the ubRMSE by up to 17 %.
Uncertainties in hydrological simulations can be quantified and reduced through data assimilation (DA). This study explores strategies for assimilating soil moisture (SM) data from Cosmic-Ray Neutron Sensors (CRNS) and groundwater level (GWL) data into the Terrestrial System Modeling Platform (TSMP), which integrates both land surface and subsurface processes. DA experiments incorporating both state and parameter estimation were performed using the localized Ensemble Kalman Filter (LEnKF) within a representative catchment in Germany over the period 2016 to 2018, with cross-validation conducted on non-overlapping years. Univariate assimilation of SM reduced the unbiased root mean square error (ubRMSE) by approximately 50 %, while univariate assimilation of GWL achieved up to a 70 % reduction in ubRMSE at assimilation sites. Improvements in GWL estimates extended up to 5 km from the assimilation points, with ubRMSE reductions ranging between 2 % and 50 %. However, assimilating GWL independently had a negative effect on SM representation, and similarly, assimilating SM alone degraded GWL predictions. To address these issues, a novel multivariate DA framework was developed, enabling SM and GWL to be assimilated independently through separate modules. Groundwater data were used to constrain the water table position, thereby improving the estimation of the boundary between unsaturated and saturated zones and allowing updates to hydraulic conditions within the saturated zone. Meanwhile, SM data improved the representation of hydrological processes in the unsaturated zone. The multivariate assimilation approach resulted in comparable improvements in GWL, SM, and evapotranspiration (ET) at the assimilation sites. Moreover, including parameter estimation alongside state updating further reduced the ubRMSE by up to 17 %.
The hydrological observatory for the Rur catchment (2400 km2) in Germany is highly equipped including 15 Cosmic Ray Neutron Sensors (CRNS) to measure soil moisture content, 6 eddy covariance stations with measurement of land-atmosphere exchange fluxes and further micrometeorological observations, and additional monitoring stations for river discharge and groundwater levels, amongst others. In addition, 3 intensive research sites at representative locations have been implemented with distributed soil moisture and temperature monitoring. These measurements allow for a better local verification of terrestrial model predictions, and the improvement of model predictions by model-data fusion methods. We did a series of studies on the assimilation of observations from the Rur observatory to improve predictions with the Terrestrial Systems Modelling Platform (TSMP), which models water, energy, carbon and nitrogen cycles of the land surface and subsurface. The data assimilation algorithm was in most cases the Ensemble Kalman Filter, but also the Particle Filter and Markov Chain Monte Carlo were used. Assimilated observations included soil moisture (from FDR-probes, CRNS or remote sensing), groundwater levels and net ecosystem exchange. We found that assimilation improved the characterization of the measured variable, also at verification locations. However, states and fluxes of variables that were not assimilated, such as evapotranspiration, often were not better characterized. The results suggest the importance of the joint assimilation of measurements for different variables, including remotely sensed information and vegetation information.