Despite the potential of extrusion-based printing of thermoplastic polymers in bone tissue engineering, the inherent nonporous stiff nature of the printed filaments may elicit immune responses that influence bone regeneration. In this study, bone scaffolds made of polycaprolactone (PCL) filaments with different internal microporosity and stiffness was 3D-printed. It was achieved by combining three fabrication techniques, salt leaching and 3D printing at either low or high temperatures (LT/HT) with or without nonsolvent induced phase separation (NIPS). Printing PCL at HT resulted in stiff scaffolds (modulus of elasticity (E): 403 ± 19 MPa and strain: 6.6 ± 0.1%), while NIPS-based printing at LT produced less stiff and highly flexible scaffolds (E: 53 ± 10 MPa and strain: 435 ± 105%). Moreover, the introduction of porosity by salt leaching in the printed filaments significantly changed the mechanical properties and degradation rate of the scaffolds. Furthermore, this study aimed to show how these variations influence proliferation and osteogenic differentiation of human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stromal cells (hBMSC) and the maturation and activation of human monocyte-derived dendritic cells (Mo-DC). The cytocompatibility of the printed scaffolds was confirmed by live-dead imaging, metabolic activity measurement, and the continuous proliferation of hBMSC over 14 days. While all scaffolds facilitated the expression of osteogenic markers (RUNX2 and Collagen I) from hBMSC as detected through immunofluorescence staining, the variation in porosity and stiffness notably influenced the early and late mineralization. Furthermore, the flexible LT scaffolds, with porosity induced by NIPS and salt leaching, stimulated Mo-DC to adopt a pro-inflammatory phenotype marked by a significant increase in the expression of IL1B and TNF genes, alongside decreased expression of anti-inflammatory markers, IL10 and TGF1B. Altogether, the results of the current study demonstrate the importance of tailoring porosity and stiffness of PCL scaffolds to direct their biological performance toward a more immune-mediated bone healing process.
Functionally graded scaffolds (FGSs) designed for bone tissue regeneration exhibit three-dimensional (3D) constructs with spatially varying pores, mirroring the natural bone structure, aiming to offer temporary support and a conducive environment for cells during tissue regeneration in defect sites. While existing research on FGSs has primarily focused on altering pore architecture and tuning biomechanical properties for improved tissue regeneration, limited exploration exists on 3D spatially varying FGSs with multiscale porosity to closely mimic natural bone. In this study, we fabricated and investigated FGSs with macropores varying radially and longitudinally, along with micropores within the struts. Utilizing nonsolvent-induced phase separation integrated with 3D printing, we printed poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL)/hydroxyapatite (HA) composite scaffolds with both uniform and FG geometries. Two HA content variations (10 and 20 wt %) were employed to assess their impact on scaffold properties. Rheological analysis of polymer suspensions gauged the viscosity and shear stress. Thermogravimetric analysis (thermal gravimetric analysis) determined PCL decomposition and the final HA content in the scaffold. Morphological properties, including porosity, pore size, and pore distribution, were evaluated using microcomputed tomography (micro-CT), while field-emission scanning electron microscopy imaged scaffold surface and cross-sectional morphology. Mechanical tests (compression and tension) assessed the scaffold strength. In vitro assays with MC3T3-E1 preosteoblast cells measured cell viability and alkaline phosphatase enzyme activity in uniform and FGSs with 10% and 20% HA content. Results confirmed that the achieved porosity levels provided sufficient strength and supported effective cell proliferation. Cell culture results demonstrated that uniform scaffolds with 10% HA promoted osteogenesis with slow cell proliferation, whereas FGSs with 20% HA promoted both proliferation and osteogenesis of preosteoblast cells. Overall, the structural, compositional, and biological characterization indicated that both uniform and FGSs provide suitable environments for bone tissue regeneration, with functionally graded scaffold morphology potentially offering a favorable environment for cell response.
Extrusion-based 3D printing of thermoplastic polymers presents significant potential for bone tissue engineering. However, a key limitation is the frequent absence of filament porosity and the inherent osteoconductive properties. This study addresses these challenges by fabricating poly(lactide-co-trimethylene carbonate) (PLATMC) scaffolds with dual-scale porosity: macroporosity achieved through controlled filament spacing and microporosity introduced via NaCl leaching. The inclusion of NaCl generated rough, porous surfaces that were well-suited for dip-coating with magnesium-carbonate-doped hydroxyapatite (MgCHA), thereby imparting osteoconductive functionality. Thermal analysis revealed that salt incorporation had minimal impact on the polymer's thermal stability. Rheological studies and computational modeling indicated that NaCl reduced the viscosity under shear, leading to enhanced printability and faster extrusion speeds. After leaching, the scaffolds exhibited approximately 34% microporosity, which significantly increased water uptake and swelling capacity, despite the roughened surfaces slightly elevating hydrophobicity. The mechanical properties of PLATMC (with nonporous filaments) and p-PLATMC (with porous filaments) scaffolds showed a modulus of elasticity of 566 ± 118 and 101 ± 20 MPa, respectively, with strain values of 178 ± 54% and 84 ± 28%. Biological evaluations highlighted the compatibility of the p-PLATMC scaffolds. Cell viability and proliferation assays confirmed sustained cellular interaction over a 14 day period. Notably, alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity was elevated in the porous scaffolds, and the MgCHA coating significantly enhanced mineral deposition by day 28, suggesting improved osteogenic potential. In conclusion, this study presents a robust strategy for fabricating 3D-printed PLATMC scaffolds with integrated filament porosity, offering a viable platform for osteoconductive coatings in bone tissue engineering applications.