Background: Mental health for engineering undergraduates is an urgent topic for engineering educators. Narratives of engineering education requiring suffering may create or exacerbate problematic perceptions around stress and mental health in engineering. This study explored the roles of stress and mental health in engineering culture. We sought to explore: (1) how engineering students describe their experiences related to stress and mental health and (2) norms and expectations engineering students share about stress and mental health. Qualitative interview data were collected from 30 students who had previously responded to a college-wide survey.Results: Codes related to experiences with stress and mental health in engineering were organized in a bioecological systems model and analyzed for emergent themes depicting engineering culture. The study identified three themes related to stress and mental health in engineering culture: (1) engineering workload as a defining stressor, (2) specific barriers that prevent engineering students from seeking help for mental health concerns, and (3) reliance on peers to cope with stress and mental health distress.Conclusions: Our analysis provided insight into how engineering students perceive norms around stress and mental health in engineering and how this impacts help-seeking for mental health challenges. These findings have important implications for developing interventions and positive cultures that support student mental health.
Background: Undergraduate engineering students report increased rates of mental health distress. Evidence suggests that these students experience high stress, which can perpetuate mental health challenges. Further, engineering students may engage in help-seeking and self-care activities more rarely than students in other disciplines. We hypothesize the existence of a culture of high stress that is normalized and expected by undergraduate engineering students. We leveraged interviews previously conducted by our team to develop two survey measures: (1) the Engineering Stress Culture (ESC) Scale, which measures cultural norms and expectations surrounding stress, and (2) the Undergraduate Engineering Stressors Questionnaire (U-ESQ), which measures factors that contribute to undergraduate engineering student stress experiences (stressors). Results: We developed a novel, exploratory battery of items to measure students’ experiences with stress in undergraduate engineering education. After administering the new 81-item survey (N = 624) comprising both the U-ESQ and ESC Scale, we performed exploratory factor analysis and tested the internal consistency for each factor subscale. We then refined the survey to 58 items and administered it to a second sample of participants (N = 561) at a second institution for confirmatory factor analyses. We present evidence that the ESC Scale is a valid and reliable instrument for measuring an engineering stress culture. The final factor structure of the U-ESQ revealed eight distinct factors, each representing different stressors such as competition or identity-related experiences. We provide validity evidence for the U-ESQ. While the confirmatory evidence of the reliability of the U-ESQ instrument is less robust compared to the ESC Scale, there is acceptable evidence of reliability. This may be partially attributed to the inclusion of career-related and faculty-interaction-related stressors that may become more for salient later-stage undergraduate students, who are undersampled in our results. Conclusions: We present validity and reliability evidence for the developed measures that quantify engineering student stressors and the associated high-stress culture. These measures may apply to students in other non-engineering STEM disciplines, warranting future investigations. The developed measure is a first step towards identifying and dismantling a culture of stress in engineering, which will promote student well-being and thriving.
27 August 2020 in Biomedical Engineering Education