Objectives To identify and prioritise important research questions for miscarriage. Design A priority setting partnership using prospective surveys and consensus meetings following methods advocated by the James Lind Alliance. Setting UK. Participants Women and those affected by miscarriage working alongside healthcare professionals. Results In the initial survey, 1093 participants (932 women who have experienced miscarriage, 8 partners, 17 family members, friends or colleagues, 104 healthcare professionals and eight charitable organisations) submitted 3279 questions. A review of existing literature identified a further 64. Non-questions were removed, and the remaining questions were categorised and summarised into 58 questions. In an interim electronic survey, 2122 respondents chose their top 10 priorities from the 58 summary questions. The 25 highest ranked in the survey were prioritised at a final face-to-face workshop. In summary, the top 10 priorities were ranked as follows: research into preventative treatment, emotional aspects in general, investigation, relevance of pre-existing medical conditions, emotional support as a treatment, importance of lifestyle factors, importance of genetic and chromosomal causes, preconception tests, investigation after different numbers of miscarriage and male causal factors. Conclusions These results should be the focus of future miscarriage research. Presently, studies are being conducted to address the top priority; however, many other priorities, especially psychological and emotional support, are less well researched areas. We hope our results will encourage both researchers and funders to focus on these priorities.
Background/Objectives: Tubal dysfunction may be a contributing factor in up to 35% of infertility cases, rendering tubal patency assessment a vital component of the infertility workup. In this review we examined the diagnostic efficacy and tolerability of hysterosalpingo-foam sonography (HyFoSy) and compared it to hysterosalpingography (HSG) and hysterosalpingo-contrast sonography (HyCoSy). Methods: Online databases were systematically searched and evaluated according to the PRISMA 2020 guidelines. Statistical heterogeneity was assessed. Diagnostic sensitivity, specificity and inter-method agreement were evaluated, along with mean pain scores. Results: This analysis included data from 9 studies and 1354 patients with conclusive diagnostic data from 2422 tubes and 1294 patients with data on intra-procedural pain. With regard to HyFoSy and HyCoSy comparison, pooled sensitivity was 87% and 69%, respectively (p = 0.074), while pooled specificity was 95% and 85%, respectively, favoring HyFoSy (p < 0.001). HyFoSy was more tolerable with regard to pain, but this was not statistically significant. Regarding the HyFoSy and HSG comparison, pooled Cohen’s k was 0.38, indicating fair-moderate agreement. In subsequent analysis, with HSG as a reference standard, HyFoSy demonstrated low sensitivity (61%) but high specificity (87%). With regard to experienced pain, HyFoSy and HSG had a difference of 2.4 units on a 10-point scale, favoring HyFoSy (p < 0.001). Conclusions: HyFoSy was superior to HyCoSy and may be used as a first-line tubal assessment method, with HSG being utilized in inconclusive cases. However, further research is still required due to the small number of available studies.