Introduction: Kidney transplantation (KT) from living donors has been shown to have multiple benefits compared to those from deceased donors. We sought to compare significant graft outcomes, namely acute rejection (AR), graft function, and survival between transplant recipients who received a kidney from living related donor (LRD) and living unrelated donor (LURD). Methods: Our cohort comprised 198 donor and recipient pairs undergoing living-donor KT at our center over 10 years. The LRD recipients were compared with LURD recipients according to demographic and clinical characteristics, transplant variables (including immunosuppression), graft function, survival, and AR rate. Results: The estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) was similar in both groups over the follow-up time i.e., 60-65 mL/min (p>0.05 over 10 years). Censored graft survival was similar between LRD and LURD recipients (96.9% vs. 98.0% at five years and 87.8% vs. 79.4% at 10 years, respectively; p=0.837). The LURD recipients had a higher incidence of AR, although LURD recipient status was not an independent risk factor for AR. Multivariate analysis showed that human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DR mismatch (MM) was an independent predictor of AR (hazard ratio (HR) 2.256, p<0.05). Both HLA-A and HLA-B MM did not affect the AR HR between the groups. Conclusion: Graft function and censored graft survival rates were similar between LURD and LRD KT recipients in our study. The AR was higher in LURD recipients, although the LURD recipient status was not an independent risk factor for AR. The HLA-DR MM was an independent predictor of AR, while HLA-A and HLA-B MM did not affect AR HR between groups of patients.
Limited information exists concerning the clinical significance of histologically confirmed antibody-mediated rejection (h-AMR) without detectable circulating donor-specific antibodies (DSA). In this study, we compared the outcomes of patients with h-AMR according to DSA status. A total of 80 kidney transplant (KT) recipients who met the 2018 Banff criteria for h-AMR were included. Clinical and immunological characteristics were evaluated, and outcomes were compared according to DSA status after kidney biopsy (KB). There were 57 patients who had DSA-positive (+) h-AMR and 23 patients who had DSA-negative (-) h-AMR. Groups had similar baseline characteristics and time between KT and KB. Concerning histopathological diagnoses/Banff scores, DSA+ patients had higher interstitial fibrosis (ci) and tubular atrophy (ct) (ci+ct) scores and lower arterial hyalinosis (ah) scores compared to DSA- patients. Graft survival (GS) was similar for both groups (64% versus 44% at five years and 44% versus 34% at 10 years). Multivariate analysis revealed the time of KB (less than six months after KT or more than six months after KT) to be associated with GS. A stratified analysis was conducted, targeting DSA status according to the time of biopsy. For KB performed less than six months after KT, GS was higher for DSA+ patients at 10 years (66% versus 23%). For KB performed more than six months after KT, DSA- patients had higher GS at 10 years (58% versus 9%). Both the timing of AMR diagnosis and DSA status had an impact on AMR outcomes. For patients diagnosed with AMR more than six months after transplantation, GS was worst for those in which circulating DSA were identified. Biopsy specimens from DSA- specimens had higher ct-ci and ah scores.