Digital transformation embeds smart cities, e-health, and Industry 4.0 into critical infrastructures, thereby increasing reliance on digital systems and exposure to cyber threats and boosting complexity and dependency. Research involving over 200 executives reveals that under rising complexity, only 15% of cyber risk investments are effective, leaving most organizations misaligned or vulnerable. In this context, the role of artificial intelligence (AI) in cybersecurity requires systemic scrutiny. This study analyzes how AI reshapes systemic structures in cyber risk management through a multi-method approach: literature review, expert workshops with practitioners and policymakers, and a structured kill chain analysis of the Colonial Pipeline attack. The findings reveal three new feedback loops: (1) deceptive defense structures that misdirect adversaries while protecting assets, (2) two-step success-to-success attacks that disable defenses before targeting infrastructure, and (3) autonomous proliferation when AI applications go rogue. These dynamics shift cyber risk from linear patterns to adaptive, compounding interactions. The principal conclusion is that AI both amplifies and mitigates systemic risk. The core recommendation is to institutionalize deception in security standards and address drifting AI-powered systems. Deliverables include validated systemic structures, policy options, and a foundation for creating future simulation models to support strategic cyber risk management investment.
In this research, we developed a novel approach to enable a dynamic cyber risk management strategy as the dynamic nature of cyber risk is rarely considered in current decision support tools. Our explorative case study shows that many management challenges such as investment decisions, priority setting, and “shelf time” analyses can be continuously analyzed. Our research using system thinking and modelling provides valuable insights about these challenges to support current strategic decision-making practices and improve managerial learning. These insights enable management to identify and analyze the effectiveness of future cyber risk management strategies before implementing them.
Organizations face growing cyber threats that expose the limitations of traditional risk management approaches focused on prevention. While cyber risk management and cyber resilience are complementary, they are often developed in isolation, leading to overemphasis on short-term mitigation at the expense of long-term adaptive capabilities. This study proposes a conceptual system dynamics model that integrates both domains through the mechanisms of resilience-informed risk management (RIRM) and risk-informed resilience (RIR). Drawing on the capability trap perspective, the model explains how resource allocation between operational activities and capability development shapes organizational cybersecurity performance over time. By capturing the dynamic interaction between preventive and adaptive capabilities across disruption phases, the framework highlights how organizations can escape reactive cycles and achieve more balanced and resilient cybersecurity governance.