In this study, high-temperature uniaxial tensile tests were performed on IN718 superalloy samples fabricated using Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) and compared to wrought IN718 superalloy samples. The mechanical properties and Portevin–Le Chatelier (PLC) behavior of WAAM IN718 were analyzed, with particular attention paid to its anisotropy and differences from its wrought counterpart. WAAM specimens were obtained from three distinct orientations within the printed blocks. The results indicated that WAAM IN718 exhibited a higher yield strength but reduced failure elongation compared to wrought IN718. Among the WAAM samples, the yield strength was highest in the transverse direction, followed by the in-depth direction, and lowest in the growth direction. Post-aging treatment significantly increased the yield strength of WAAM IN718. WAAM IN718 showed a larger critical strain for the onset of serrated flow and smaller stress drop amplitudes compared to wrought IN718 under the PLC effect. Furthermore, as the strain rate decreased, PLC serrations in WAAM specimens from the in-depth direction transitioned from type A to type C. Conversely, specimens from the growth direction maintained type B serrations at a strain rate of ${10}^{-4}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$. This study also examined potential factors influencing the differences in PLC behavior and conducted an analysis of the fracture surfaces across various specimens.