The 2011 Tropical Storm Irene deposited 100–200 mm of rain in Vermont with a rainfall recurrence interval for a 12-hour storm exceeding 500 years in some areas. This single hurricane-related event damaged over 300 bridges. The wide range of damage prompted a networkwide analysis of flood, scour, stream and structural conditions. A first step was the assembly of a unique data set containing information on 326 damaged bridges, 1936 undamaged bridges and the surrounding stream conditions. Descriptions of the damage appear as case studies that include pre-storm bridge and stream geomorphology conditions. The assembled and georeferenced data include rainfall, damage type and extent, estimated and actual repair costs, bridge characteristics, bridge ratings and stream geomorphic assessments from a number of sources. The analyses identified significant features of bridge vulnerability under extreme floods. The bridge age and rating assessment characteristics, such as substructure, channel and structural adequacy ratings, followed by scour, waterway adequacy and sufficiency ratings, correlated strongly to damage. The stream geomorphic features have promise to supplement future bridge rating systems and in identifying hydraulic vulnerability of bridges. Empirical fragility curves relating probability of meeting or exceeding different bridge damage levels based on channel and waterway adequacy ratings are also presented.
1 February 2016 in Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering
Seismic design of geotechnical structures often requires estimates of how shearing resistance of liquefiable soil is reduced to its minimum value (residual strength, ) as pore pressures build up and is subsequently regained as pore pressures dissipate. It was envisioned that the shear strength of liquefying sands could be measured in-flight in a seismic geotechnical centrifuge model by pulling thin coupons (plates) horizontally through the sand models before, during, and after shaking to simulate the large strains and strain rates associated with liquefaction flow failures. This paper presents the results of seismic centrifuge tests that were used to make such measurements. Companion ring shear (RS) tests also are described. Although centrifuge and RS residual strengths were generally similar and increased with relative density, the centrifuge and ( divided by preshaking effective vertical stress) increased significantly with small changes in relative density, while the RS test and increased only slightly with changes in relative density. Furthermore, many measured and values fell below penetration test-based design curves used in practice. Dilative tendency during shearing is believed to have resulted in a dramatic increase in and in the centrifuge tests that consisted of soil dense of the critical state. In contrast, RS tests likely resulted in shear band development, where intense shearing and particle damage occurs, leading to suppressed soil dilative tendency and divergence from the centrifuge test results at higher relative densities. The centrifuge tests provided evidence that, as expected, postliquefaction strength recovery is linearly proportional to effective stress as excess pore pressures dissipate.
On August 28, 2011, Tropical Storm Irene hit the state of Vermont with a severity that deposited 100–200 mm (4–8 in.) of rain across the state and resulted in damage or failure of over 300 bridges. The analysis of available data sets helped identify a set of 313 bridges (with a span greater than 6 m) damaged in a single state from a single extreme flood event that caused a 12-h rainfall recurrence interval that exceeded 500 years in some areas and 100 years throughout most of the affected areas. Based on available damage reports and photographs, the observed bridge damage was grouped into four levels of severity. This paper links watershed stream power to the observed bridge damage, develops a process for quantifying the hazard at bridges both as a case study and for future storms, and uses stream power as a hazard metric to produce probabilistic predictions of bridge vulnerability. The analysis also offers a comparison between damaged bridges and bridges that were not damaged in Tropical Storm Irene. Specific stream power (SSP) and the event-based Irene-specific stream power (ISSP) were computed and found to be both statistically significant at discriminating between damaged and nondamaged bridges, as well as between damage levels. The application of the empirical fragility curve analysis for SSP and ISSP produces a probability of damage generated from the results collected from Tropical Storm Irene. Spatially mapping the bridge-damage probability from an extreme event like Tropical Storm Irene enables the hazard to be effectively displayed over a broad range of scales (e.g., stream reaches, select watershed, statewide). The methodology presented here can be applied to other geographic settings and storm events of interest, and to the best of the authors’ knowledge, this is the first investigation comparing site-specific stream power to observed bridge damage at a network level.
1 January 2014 in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
For cast-in-place abutments and retaining walls, structural backfill is preferred to be free-draining, which generally implies less than 5% fines content. This fines content is expected to eliminate the need to design for hydrostatic pressures. The availability of high-quality structural backfill with naturally low fines content is declining. This situation warrants an evaluation of whether granular backfill materials with greater than 5% fines content could be successfully used in practice. Flexible wall, hydraulic conductivity tests on a granular structural backfill with 0%, 5%, 10%, 15%, 20%, and 25% nonplastic fines content were conducted at 41, 83, and 124 kPa (6, 12, and 18 psi) confining pressures followed by consolidated drained triaxial compression tests for obtaining associated drained shear strength parameters of these gradations. The 15.2-cm (6-in.) diameter specimens were prepared at optimum moisture content and 95% of maximum standard Proctor density. To enable a comparison with respect to modified Proctor maximum densities, modified Proctor tests were also performed for all base soil–fines content mixtures. The experimental results were compared with relevant studies found in the literature. This research indicates that a nonplastic fines content up to 10% may be justified in structural backfill specifications for retaining walls and abutments.
This paper presents a conceptual framework of how some recent efforts aimed at using data gained from automated and robotic structural sensing systems can be incorporated into Building Information Modeling (BIM) systems leading to a comprehensive, intelligent structural health management system. Robotic and similar automated systems may extend the reach of structural sensing systems to realms and modes that are impractical with other systems. This paper begins with a brief discussion of the operational principles of the following automated inspections systems: (1) Multisensor assessment of concrete corrosion damage; (2) Low-cost high-quality image processing for structural condition; (3) Quadcopter UAV for remote imaging of structural condition; (4) Suction foot robot for climbing on brick and concrete walls; (5) Wheeled robot with active stereo imaging system that measures structural shapes; and (6) Lidar imaging system with integration into BIM. These systems carry onboard sensors, such as 3-D optical imagers and ground penetrating radar. Issues when using these systems include: (1) Position registration and navigation; (2) Sensing system performance and operational procedures; (3) Safety; and (4) Intelligent integration of sensing data into structural database. The present state of the art is that these types of systems work reasonably well and can generate large data streams that quickly overwhelm manual management methods. A possible path of automated data management is to tie the data directly to a structural database. BIM is presented as a potential framework for data integration, synthesis, retrieval and rapid display of data in graphical formats tied to the structure, in a level of detail hierarchy.
Streambank erosion is an important component of geomorphic responses to channel changes that affect a wide range of physical, ecological, and socio-economic issues in the fluvial environment including water quality and on- and near-stream infrastructure. A number of direct (e.g., longitudinal surveys, erosion pins, remote sensing) and indirect (e.g., process-based models) methods have been used to quantify streambank erosion. These methods are not only very resource intensive, but many are feasible and appropriate only for site-specific studies and not suitable or practical for erosion estimates at larger scales. Recent developments in unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) provide opportunities for rapidly and economically quantifying streambank erosion and deposition at variable scales (from site-specific to river network), and is the focus of this paper. At the site-specific scale, the capability of UAS to quantify streambank erosion was assessed by comparing it to terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) and RTK (real time kinematic) GPS for validation. At the individual site level, the estimation of bank erosion using UAS was within 4% of the actual erosion at a surveyed cross-section. At the river network-level scale, initial results indicate even bank retreats of less than a meter can be detected, provided banks are not completely obscured by dense vegetation.