The aim of this study was to compare, during milking, the bacteriomes of goat milk from farms in Mexico representing traditional and semi-intensive production systems. Metagenomic DNA was isolated from pooled milk samples collected at different milking stages, and following 16S rRNA-targeted sequencing, alpha (Shannon H’ and Simpson D) and beta (Bray–Curtis) diversity indices were calculated. Within the semi-intensive system, fore-stripping showed lower diversity (H’ = 1.5 vs. H’ = 4.0) but greater evenness (D = 0.5 vs. D = 0.8) than the milking stage. In contrast, no differences between stages in the traditional system were observed. The Bray–Curtis index revealed that the use of the semi-intensive system explained 99.4% of the variability, while the traditional system accounted for only 0.5%. In the semi-intensive system, fore-stripping was dominated by Mesoplasma (51.9%) and Staphylococcus (42.1%), whereas Enterococcus (27.2%) and Lactococcus (18.5%) prevailed during milking. Meanwhile, in the traditional system, Pseudomonas (46.9% and 22.7) and Lactococcus (22.7% and 29.2%) predominated in both stages. Management practices strongly influence the microbiological profile of milk, leading to changes in not only the diversity and abundance of pathogenic bacteria but also in the presence of beneficial lactic acid bacteria and, hence, the overall expected milk quality.