The European Green Deal and the Farm to Fork Strategy outline the European Union's strategy to sustainably address growing global food demand. The European Commission's guidelines for sustainable aquaculture by 2030 emphasize the sector's crucial role in this goal, particularly by promoting the use of alternative raw materials in aquafeeds to reduce reliance on fishmeal and help preserve wild fish stocks. Insects and their ability to recover nutrients from human and animal waste represent a circular alternative nutrient source that could be integrated into aquafeeds. Several obstacles still exist for adopting insect-based feeds in aquaculture, and one is represented by the consumer's acceptance, especially in Western societies. Since data regarding consumer acceptance of indirect entomophagy is still lacking, the idea of this study stems from the intention to contribute knowledge on this issue. A multivariate analysis method was used on a sample of 2426 consumers, and it allowed the identification of three groups of consumers. In general, consumers lack interest in the sustainability aspects of aquaculture production, and thus in the consumption of aquaculture productions fed with insect meal emerged, highlighting the lack of understanding of the relevance of shifting from the linear models to a circular economy approach in the aquaculture sector. The effect of information on the potential improvement of sustainability in the sector, and thus on the benefits of introducing insect meal, promoted an average 15% increase in each group to purchase these products. These results confirm the need to promote knowledge and information systems in Italy to build the so-called blue economy.
This study investigates Italian fishery discards through the lens of neglected and underutilized species (NUS). It estimates the potential loss of value (PLoV) to identify pathways for sustainable valorization under the European Union landing obligation (LO). NUS were selected through a stakeholder focus group. Data regarding landings and discards were collected for the period 2020–2022 within the Italian Ministry of Agriculture, Food Sovereignty, and Forestry (MASAF) database. Among the three years, fleets landed roughly 130,400 tons annually, worth about €700 million, while discarding around 6200 tons yearly. This corresponds to an average PLoV of approximately €21.5 million. Most of the discarded quantity and value is concentrated in a few species. Atlantic Horse Mackerel stands out, accounting for nearly one-third of discarded biomass and about one-quarter of total PLoV. In 2020 and 2022, its discards even exceeded reported landings. A conservative valorization scenario for this single species indicates potential revenues of up to €7.5 million per year. Overall, these findings suggest that targeted NUS valorization could represent a way to diversify seafood consumption, alleviate pressure on common stocks, and buffer fishers’ incomes. This potential depends on ensuring traceability and safety, supported by pilots in processing, product development, and consumer acceptance.
27 December 2025 in Agricultural and Food Economics
Novel feed ingredients have emerged in response to the growing sustainability and circularity challenges facing aquaculture. Among these, insect meal derived from black soldier fly ( Hermetia illucens) has attracted increasing attention for its potential to support circular production models. However, the adoption of such innovations remains limited, and existing studies often overlook how adoption evolves beyond the initial uptake. In this context, the present study applies the AKAIE framework—Awareness, Knowledge, Adoption, Implementation, and Effectiveness—to examine the adoption process of Hermetia illucens meal among 28 Italian trout farmers. The analysis reveals dynamics often neglected in adoption studies by identifying four farmer profiles: Non-adopters, Experimenters, Partial Adopters, and Advanced Adopters. Results indicate that farmers perceive insect meal as an incremental innovation requiring minimal adjustments to existing practices, although high feed costs and limited consumer acceptance persist as major barriers. Environmental benefits are the most widely recognized, while economic and social advantages appear less evident. By integrating the post-adoption dimension, this research aims to advance the understanding of innovation diffusion in aquaculture. The AKAIE framework could represent a practical tool for policymakers seeking to monitor the diffusion of circular feed innovations and the factors influencing their implementation under the European sustainability agenda.
Mussel aquaculture plays an important role in the economies and livelihoods of coastal communities, supporting income generation, employment, and the preservation of local production traditions. However, the sector relies heavily on plastic materials, particularly polypropylene (PP) nets, whose extensive use raises environmental concerns related to marine pollution. While interest in biodegradable and recycled alternatives is growing, their adoption remains limited by technical, economic, organizational, and market barriers. This exploratory study examines the perceptions of a nonrandom sample of 22 mussel farmers operating in Italy regarding the use of alternative materials for farming nets, identifying perceived drivers and obstacles to their adoption. Using a contingent valuation approach, the study describes farmers’ stated willingness to pay (WTP) for recycled polypropylene (RPP) and biodegradable and compostable plastic (BP) nets. Among respondents who provided valid WTP responses, the median WTP was €4.5/kg in both the preinformation and postinformation elicitation conditions for RPP nets ( n = 14) and BP nets ( n = 15); the corresponding mean values ranged from €4.11 to €4.17/kg. The results suggest that concerns about quality, high costs, and limited consumer acceptance are relevant perceived barriers within the surveyed sample. A simplified parametric scenario model was then used to compare farmers’ perceptions with indicative cost implications under specific market and operational assumptions. The simulations suggest that, under selected assumptions, mixed‐material strategies combining conventional and alternative polymers may generate costs close to those of conventional plastic nets within the scenario considered. The findings provide exploratory and sample‐specific evidence on the perceived and economic conditions that may shape the adoption of alternative net materials among the surveyed mussel farmers in Italy.