Lennert-Cody, C. E., Roberts, J. J., and Stephenson, R. J. 2008. Effects of gear characteristics on the presence of bigeye tuna (Thunnus obesus) in the catches of the purse-seine fishery of the eastern Pacific Ocean. – ICES Journal of Marine Science, 65: 970–978.
The previously published index of relative abundance of the northeastern offshore stock of spotted dolphins, the species most affected by the purse-seine fishery for tunas in the eastern Pacific Ocean, shows a decreasing trend in the last two decades despite dramatic reductions in incidental mortality since the early 1970s. To better understand the behaviour of this index, the effects of changes in data quality and methods of searching on estimation of relative abundance using current methodologies have been studied here. Changes in data quality since the late 1980s have led to a dramatic reduction in the proportion of sightings that are reported on or near the trackline. The decreasing trend in the index in the late 1970s and through the 1980s is strongly influenced by the fit of the detection function to the high proportion of sightings near the trackline that was present in the data during that time period. If this excess of sightings near the trackline is spurious, then much of the decreasing trend in the index over this time period is likely spurious. In addition, part of the decrease in the index in the late 1980s to mid-1990s is probably due to changes in data-collection biases that result from a dramatic increase in the amount of searching that is currently being carried out using helicopters as compared to high-powered binoculars. The results suggest that trends in bias associated with changes in data quality and fishery operations may have contributed to a trend in the index on the order of 1.0-1.5% per year, or approximately 25-33% of the maximum growth rate of the northeastern stock of offshore spotted dolphin. The pervasive nature of these sources of bias, and their potential magnitude relative to the maximum growth rates of the dolphin species involved, make use of this index in population growth models ill-advised. Fishery-derived indices such as these may be most useful for comparing trends in relative abundance between species, when the sources of biases are unlikely to be species-specific.
A twelve-year hiatus in fishery-independent marine mammal surveys in the eastern tropical Pacific Ocean (ETP), combined with a mandate to monitor dolphin stock status under international agreements and the need for reliable stock status information to set dolphin bycatch limits in the tuna purse-seine fishery, has renewed debate about how best to assess and monitor ETP dolphin stock status. The high cost of replicating previous ship-based surveys has intensified this debate. In this review, transect methods for estimating animal abundance from dedicated research surveys are considered, with a focus on both contemporary and potential methods suitable for surveying large areas for dolphin species that can form large, multi-species aggregations. Covered in this review are potential improvements to the previous ship-based survey methodology, other ship-based methods, alternative approaches based on high-resolution imagery and passive acoustics, and combinations of ship-based and alternative approaches. It is concluded that for immediate management needs, ship-based surveys, with some suggested modifications to improve precision, are the only reliable option despite their high cost. However, it is recommended that a top research priority should be development of composite methods. Pilot studies on the use of high-resolution imagery and passive acoustics for development of indices of relative abundance to be used in composite methods should be part of any future ship-based survey efforts.