BACKGROUND Briefing of the trauma team before patient arrival is unstructured in many centers. We surveyed trauma teams regarding agreement on patient care priorities and evaluated the impact of a structured, physician-led briefing on concordance during simulated resuscitations. METHODS Trauma nurses at our Level II center were surveyed, and they participated in four resuscitation scenarios, randomized to “briefed” or “nonbriefed.” For nonbriefed scenarios, nurses independently reviewed triage sheets with written information. Briefed scenarios had a structured 4-minute physician-led briefing reviewing triage sheets identical to nonbriefed scenarios. Teams included three to four nurses (subjects) and two to four confederates (physicians, respiratory therapists). Each team served as their own control group. Confederates were blinded to nurses' briefed or nonbriefed status. Immediately before, and at the midpoint of each scenario, nurses estimated patients' morbidity and mortality and ranked the top 3 of 16 designated immediate care priorities. Briefed and nonbriefed groups' responses were compared for (1) agreement using intraclass correlation coefficient, (2) concordance with physicians' responses using the Fisher exact test, (3) teamwork via T-NOTECHS ratings by nurses and physicians using t-test, and (4) time to complete clinical tasks using t test. RESULTS Thirty-eight nurses participated. Ninety-seven percent “agreed/strongly agreed” briefing is important, but only 46% agreed briefing was done well. Comparing briefed versus nonbriefed scenarios, nurses' estimation of morbidity and mortality in the briefed scenarios showed significantly greater agreement with each other and with physicians' answers (p < 0.01). Rank lists also better agreed with each other (intraclass correlation coefficient, 0.64 vs 0.59) and with physicians' answers in the briefed scenarios. T-NOTECHS Leadership ratings were significantly higher in the briefed scenarios (3.70 vs 3.39; p < 0.01). Time to completion of key clinical tasks was significantly faster for one of the briefed scenarios. CONCLUSIONS Discordant perceptions of patient care goals was frequently observed. Structured physician-led briefing seemed to improve interprofessional team concordance, leadership, and task completion in simulated trauma resuscitations.
Berg B, Walker RA, Murray WB, Boedeker BH. Airway intubation in a helicopter cabin: video vs. direct laryngoscopy in manikins. Aviat Space Environ Med 2009; 80:820–3. Introduction: Airway management may be required during medical evacuation in a helicopter when patients deteriorate en route. Laryngoscopist positioning at the head of the patient may not be possible, making it difficult to perform direct laryngoscopy (DIR). An alternative method is video laryngoscopy (VID) that displays magnified images of the glottic opening on a video monitor and allows intubation despite nonstandard positioning. Methods: There were 21 experienced aeromedical emergency medical personnel who intubated a recumbent manikin with the operator seated at the head of a secured helicopter stretcher in a power-off helicopter. Each subject performed intubations using DIR and VID in standard- and difficult-airway manikins (STD and DIF, respectively). Data were collected for subjective glottic visualization grades, intubation times, and intubation success rates. Results: Visualization grades were 2.43 ± 0.81 for STD-DIR and 1.10 ± 0.30 for STD-VID, compared to 1.76 ± 0.54 for DIF-DIR and 3.72 ± 0.57 for DIF-VID. Success rates were 95% for both STD-DIR and STD-VID, 5% for DIF-DIR and 95% DIF-VID. Mean intubation time for DIF-VID was 0.90 min ± 0.80 min, not different from STD-DIR. Discussion: The success rate for difficult airway intubation by aeromedical personnel in a power-off evacuation helicopter was significantly improved by enhancing glottic visualization using VID vs. DIR in a manikin.
24 April 2023 in Clinical and Experimental Emergency Medicine
Standardized patients (SPs), people who have been trained to simulate or represent a medical condition in a standardized way, are commonly used in medical education. However, considerable effort is required to maintain a panel of SPs and trained evaluators. We conducted a study using the Access Grid advanced videoconferencing system and the Internet2 high performance research and education network at a hospital in Hawaii with medical residents and a medical school in New Mexico with an SP programme. After receiving one didactic presentation and written material about smoking cessation, three residents in Hawaii each counselled an SP in New Mexico via the Access Grid. One evaluator was located in New Mexico at an Access Grid node. Two evaluators were located in Hawaii, one in the same room as the residents, and one connected via the Access Grid. Evaluators scored the learners using 11 criteria. Student and SP feedback and inter-rater reliability among evaluators were good. Teaching and evaluating interviewing skills appear to be feasible using the Access Grid. Wider implementation of the technique will require considerable technical, logistical and curriculum coordination among participating sites.