Inflammatory fibroid polyp (IFP) or Vanek’s tumor is a rare benign submucosal lesion of the gastrointestinal tract that may radiologically mimic mesenchymal gastric tumors, particularly gastrointestinal stromal tumors. We present the case of a 65-year-old patient with a contrast-enhancing gastric submucosal mass detected on computed tomography, initially interpreted as a suspected mesenchymal neoplasm. CT imaging demonstrated a well-defined enhancing lesion arising from the gastric wall without evidence of metastatic disease. Surgical resection was performed because imaging findings were considered highly suggestive of GIST. Gross intraoperative appearance and pathological examination, however, established the final diagnosis of gastric inflammatory fibroid polyp (Vanek’s tumor). Histopathological analysis demonstrated characteristic spindle-cell proliferation with inflammatory eosinophil-rich infiltrates, while immunohistochemistry excluded GIST. This case highlights the diagnostic challenge in differentiating IFP from other gastric submucosal neoplasms based solely on imaging findings and emphasizes the importance of histopathological confirmation for definitive diagnosis.