Neil Brodie

Dr. Neil Brodie


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

6Years (2021-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
7 November 2021 in Journal of Field Archaeology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
NBNeil Brodie
Neil Brodie
MKMorag M. Kersel
Morag M. Kersel
SMSimon Mackenzie
Simon Mackenzie
ISIsber Sabrine
Isber Sabrine
ESEmiline Smith
Emiline Smith
DYDonna Yates
Donna Yates
Fifty years after the adoption of the 1970 UNESCO Convention, the illicit trade in cultural objects endures, with harmful consequences to local communities, knowledge acquisition, and archaeological landscapes and objects. In this article, we present a gap analysis to assess under-performing policy and practice. We argue that a poor understanding of how the trade is organized and operates and of how it might be regulated hinders effective policy formulation. Funding structures which encourage short-term ad hoc research and inhibit information sharing are in part responsible for some of the gaps. We conclude by suggesting how sustained theoretically informed, evidence-led collaborative analyses might help reduce or mitigate these problems, preventing another 50 years of illicit trade.

23 November 2022 in Journal of Greek Archaeology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CRColin Renfrew
Colin Renfrew
MBMichael J. Boyd
Michael J. Boyd
DADemetris Athanasoulis
Demetris Athanasoulis
NBNeil Brodie
Neil Brodie
TCTristan Carter
Tristan Carter
JWJoshua Wright
Joshua Wright
This article aims to summarise the results of three periods of fieldwork carried out since 2006. These are the Cambridge Keros Project of 2006–2008, the Keros Island Survey of 2012–2013, and the Keros-Naxos Seaways Project of 2015–2018. Taken together, these form a coherent, large-scale project that aimed to study a maritime landscape in some depth, putting the Kavos and Dhaskalio sites in a broader context, while through excavation understanding in great detail the formation, use and abandonment of the sanctuary site on Kavos and the large built-up area on Dhaskalio.

1 May 2022 in Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology and Heritage Studies
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
ISIsber Sabrine
Isber Sabrine
RARistam Abdo
Ristam Abdo
NBNeil Brodie
Neil Brodie
We present here some new evidence documenting the involvement of Da’esh with the looting and illicit trade of antiquities in northeastern Syria. We have interviewed four people who have first-hand knowledge of its activities and acquired some images of looted objects and Da’esh administrative documents. We examine this new evidence in the context of previously reported accounts of Da’esh involvement with the antiquities trade. We also report looting at some previously unknown archaeological sites, describe extensive looting when northeastern Syria was controlled by the Free Syrian Army, and critically examine the reliability of prices reported inside Syria.

1 May 2024 in International Journal of Cultural Property
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
AKAmmar Kannawi
Ammar Kannawi
SKSalam Al Quntar (Al Kuntar)
Salam Al Quntar (Al Kuntar)
DGDareen Gahli
Dareen Gahli
NBNeil Brodie
Neil Brodie
During the Syrian war, many archaeological sites were subjected to systematic looting and destruction, often on a massive scale. Among the casualties of this looting is a colossal basalt statue of a lion that was located at the archaeological site of Ain Dara in northwest Syria. The lion of Ain Dara is a prominent local symbol and of great importance for the collective memory of northwest Syria, especially for the people of Wadi Afrin. Its disappearance will also have serious repercussions for the local economy as it was, in the past, an important tourist attraction. In this article, we investigate how the statue was stolen, why it was stolen, and where it is now. By using the lion statue of Ain Dara as a case study, we aim to shed more general light on the networks responsible for looting and trafficking Syrian antiquities, the factors that have enabled their growth during the conflict, and the role of civil society organizations in reducing their harmful impact on the cultural community of the Syrian people.

1 February 2025 in Advances in Archaeological Practice
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
NBNeil Brodie
Neil Brodie
This article explores archaeological practice as regards the study and publication of unprovenanced artifacts, particularly elements of ancient arms and armor. It describes the reasons why publication is thought to be prejudicial for archaeological research and considers the possible utility of some counterarguments by way of an examination of the publication policy of the European Association of Archaeologists. It concludes by arguing that archaeologists in favor of study and publication need to do more to validate their position.

9 November 2025
Verified
Book Chapter
Open access
PDF file
NBNeil Brodie
Neil Brodie
Investigative journalism has been and continues to be an important open source of information about the antiquities trade. It should be borne in mind, however, that the aims of the investigative journalist are not necessarily concordant with those of the academic researcher or policymaker. To date, there has been no examination of any inherent weaknesses, deficiencies or biases embodied within those aims. With reference to the reporting of thefts during the 2010s of ancient gems from the British Museum, this chapter explores some possible shortcomings of investigative journalism but also demonstrates how it constitutes a valuable resource for academic research and policymaking.