As societies worldwide grapple with substantial educational inequities, understanding their underlying causes remains a priority. Here, we introduce the Brilliance–Belonging Model, a novel theoretical framework that illuminates how cultural beliefs about exceptional intellectual ability create inequities through their impact on students’ sense of belonging. The model identifies two types of widespread cultural beliefs about ability: field-specific ability beliefs (FABs) and brilliance stereotypes. FABs are cultural beliefs about the extent to which success in an educational context requires exceptional intellectual ability or “brilliance” (e.g., math more so than language). In contrast, brilliance stereotypes are cultural beliefs that associate exceptional intellectual ability with some groups more than others (e.g., individuals from high vs. low socioeconomic status backgrounds). According to the Brilliance–Belonging Model, students from groups targeted by negative brilliance stereotypes are perceived—by themselves and others—as not belonging in contexts where brilliance-oriented FABs are common. These perceptions compromise students’ psychological safety and lead to disempowering treatment by others, resulting in persistent gaps in achievement and representation. Such effects are amplified by the competitive climates to which brilliance-oriented FABs give rise, where pressure to demonstrate intellectual superiority creates particular challenges for students from intellectually stigmatized groups, who often value cooperation over competition. By revealing how cultural beliefs about intellectual ability shape educational outcomes through their effects on belonging, the Brilliance–Belonging Model provides a roadmap for interventions aimed at fostering a sustained sense of belonging among diverse students.
Previous research has often portrayed first‐generation college students – students whose parents do not have a four‐year university degree – through a deficit lens, depicting them as lacking in skills, knowledge or potential compared to continuing‐generation students. It, however, remains unknown how first‐generation and continuing‐generation students perceive themselves with respect to their own goals and obligations. Who do they want to be and to what extent do they think of themselves as meeting their own goals and obligations? To answer these questions, we assessed students' ideal and ought selves, as well as self‐discrepancies, based on Higgins's theory (Higgins, 1987), in a relatively large sample of students in the US ( N = 1244) across three waves. Overall, we found no significant differences in the content of ideal and ought selves, or perceived self‐discrepancies between first‐generation and continuing‐generation students. Responses were strikingly similar, with both groups mentioning almost identical characteristics for their ideal and ought selves. Furthermore, there were no significant differences in ideal or ought self‐discrepancies between the two groups of students. Despite common deficit narratives, first‐generation students did not think of themselves as being further away from their aspired selves than continuing‐generation students.