In the digital context, how to achieve symmetrical integration between subjective evaluation and structural stability becomes the key to improving the design effect of iterative product optimization. In this paper, we propose an iterative design method for CIHFS-DEMATEL products that incorporates structural symmetry analysis. The method is based on online review mining and constructs a credibility-based interval hesitant fuzzy set (CIHFS) to symmetrically express the ambiguity and credibility differences in the decision-maker’s subjective evaluation. In turn, a novel exact score function called credibility interval hesitant fuzzy score function (CHFSF), incorporating information symmetric weights, is proposed to realize the bidirectional symmetric mapping between subjective fuzzy inputs and objective exact outputs. Subsequently, the CIHFS-DEMATEL model is introduced to identify the causal paths and a symmetric interaction structure between potential users’ demands. Finally, the demand module mapping matrix is constructed to realize the symmetric decision-making closure loop from demand to solution. Taking the “Intelligent Classified Trash Can” as a case study, we verify the superiority of the method in terms of recognition accuracy, rationality of weight allocation, and structural stability. This study emphasizes the structural symmetry between “input–evaluation–output”, which provides a theoretical foundation and practical framework for the optimal design of products with complex multi-source information.
In complex decision-making environments, the uncertainty and hesitancy of evaluation information, coupled with differences among evaluators, lead to asymmetric characteristics in decision information and preferences. Traditional methods struggle to effectively handle scenarios where interval uncertainty and hesitant information coexist, nor can they suppress asymmetric biases caused by extreme evaluations or imbalanced information distributions. To address this, this paper proposes a Symmetric Perception Decision Framework based on credibility-based interval hesitant fuzzy information. First, a Robust Credibility-Based Interval Hesitant Fuzzy Score Function (R-CHFSF) is constructed. This function quantifies asymmetric information by integrating interval width, distribution dispersion, and hesitancy characteristics. An adaptive penalty mechanism is introduced to suppress unreasonable asymmetric amplification effects caused by anomalous intervals or extreme evaluations. Second, the R-CHFSF is embedded into DEMATEL and TODIM methods to construct an integrated model combining causal analysis and ranking decisions, forming a closed-loop decision mechanism that simultaneously regulates information asymmetry and preference asymmetry. Empirical analysis using online movie reviews demonstrates that this framework effectively suppresses interference from excessively asymmetric evaluations, enhances the robustness and interpretability of ranking results, and validates its effectiveness in asymmetry regulation and decision stability.
This study examines the characteristics of Group Multi-Attribute Decision Making (GMADM), including highly ambiguous information, divergent expert opinions, and bounded rationality among decision-makers. From the perspective of symmetry modeling and bias control, we propose an adaptive decision-making framework based on Spherical Fuzzy Sets (SFS). First, a spherical fuzzy quantification system for online reviews is constructed to map multi-source asymmetric information within reviews to Spherical Fuzzy Numbers. Second, an adaptive expert weighting mechanism is developed that integrates individual expert performance with the level of group consensus, dynamically adjusting weights to suppress the asymmetric interference of outlier opinions. Subsequently, we design the Credibility-based Spherical Weighted Arithmetic Mean (CSWAM) to preserve the dominance of expert judgments in a nonlinear manner and construct the Spherical Fuzzy Score function with Adaptive Hesitation Penalty (HP-SC) to ensure robustness and non-negativity in the defuzzification process. Furthermore, we extend DEMATEL and TODIM to the SFS environment, constructing a comprehensive evaluation model that captures causal relationships among attributes and asymmetric information, such as decision-makers’ loss aversion. Finally, empirical results from online movie review usefulness rankings demonstrate that this model can accurately identify and mitigate asymmetric information biases while maintaining decision symmetry equilibrium and exhibiting higher ranking stability.