Metabolite fingerprint profiling is a robust tool for verifying suppliers of authentic botanical ingredients. While comparative studies exist, few apply identical conditions across multiple species; this study utilized a cross-species comparison to identify versatile solvents despite biochemical variability. Multiple solvents were used for sample extraction prior to analysis by proton NMR and liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry (LC-MS) for multiple botanicals including Camellia sinensis, Cannabis sativa, Myrciaria dubia, Sambucus nigra, Zingiber officinale, Curcuma longa, Silybum marianum, Vaccinium macrocarpon, and Prunus cerasus. Comparisons were normalized by total intensity; deuterated methanol aids NMR lock but is not required for LC-MS. Hierarchical clustering analysis (HCA) evaluated solvent efficacy. Methanol–deuterium oxide (1:1) was the most effective extraction method, yielding 155 NMR spectral metabolite variables for Camellia sinensis, while methanol (90% CH3OH + 10% CD3OD) produced 198 for Cannabis sativa and 167 for Myrciaria dubia, with 11, 9, and 28 assigned metabolites, respectively. LC-MS detected 121 metabolites in Myrciaria dubia in methanol as the most effective extraction method. Methanol (10% deuterated) is the most effective extraction method for comprehensive metabolite fingerprinting using NMR and LC-MS protocols because it provides the broadest metabolite coverage. This study advances fit-for-purpose methods to qualify suppliers of botanical ingredients in food and NHP quality control programs.
Flowers are gaining considerable interest among consumers as ingredients in food, beverages, cosmetics, and natural health products. The supply chain trades in multiple forms of botanicals, including fresh whole flowers, which are easier to identify than dried flowers or flowers processed as powdered or liquid extracts. There is a gap in the scientific methods available for the verification of flower species ingredients traded in the supply chains of multiple markets. The objective of this paper is to develop methods for flower species ingredient verification using two orthogonal methods. More specifically, the objectives of this study employed both (1) DNA-based molecular diagnostic methods and (2) NMR metabolite fingerprint methods in the identification of 23 common flower species ingredients. NMR data analysis reveals considerable information on the variation in metabolites present in different flower species, including color variants within species. This study provides a comprehensive comparison of two orthogonal methods for verifying flower species ingredient supply chains to ensure the highest quality products. By thoroughly analyzing the benefits and limitations of each approach, this research offers valuable insights to support quality assurance and improve consumer confidence.
Acerola (Barbados cherries) has become a highly traded superfruit because it contains many phytonutrients and is a good source of vitamin C. The fruits of Malpighia glabra, and M. emarginata are utilized in food products, dietary supplements and natural health products. However, there are differences among the fruit of Malpighia species with respect to phytochemicals, nutrient value and clinical research. Furthermore, there is evidence of adulteration with other fruit such as cherries (Prunus spp.). Unfortunately, conventional morphological examination does not distinguish acerola fruit species. Furthermore, no published methods are available to distinguish the fruits of these species including chemical and DNA based techniques. This risk to quality assurance (QA) is increased when considering processed berries into juice or powdered ingredients of which are the most common source for manufactures. This lack of QA methods also increases the risk of adulteration with cheaper fruit from other species. The goal of this research is to provide orthogonal molecular methods to authenticate Acerola fruit ingredients and discuss the benefits and constraints of these two different methods. This research supports quality assurance (QA) programs with fit-for-purpose methods for verifying the authenticity of acerola species ingredients from suppliers.