Community participation is widely recognized as a core pillar of effective School Improvement Programs (SIP), yet participation in many Ethiopian schools remains below policy expectations. This study investigated the extent and nature of community involvement in SIP implementation in secondary schools in Kembata Zone, analyzing the structural, cultural, and economic factors shaping engagement. A descriptive survey design and mixed-methods approach were employed, involving 234 participants including teachers, principals, supervisors, GEQIP experts, and PSTA, SIC, and KETB representatives. Data were collected through questionnaires, semi-structured interviews, focus group discussions, and document review, and analyzed using descriptive statistics, one-way ANOVA, and thematic analysis. Findings show that community involvement is largely limited to financial or material contributions, with minimal participation in governance, planning, or monitoring. Significant barriers include low awareness of SIP objectives, limited capacity and empowerment, financial constraints, unclear policy guidelines, and weak communication and leadership practices in schools. ANOVA results revealed significant differences among stakeholder groups in perceptions of participation and leadership support. The study concludes that strengthening community capacity, clarifying roles, enhancing participatory leadership, and institutionalizing inclusive decision-making structures are critical for improving SIP implementation. These measures address local participation gaps while advancing the broader aims of Sustainable Development Goal 4 by promoting equitable, accountable, and collaborative school environments.