Comparative assessment of natural and synthetic reproductive inhibitors in Oreochromis niloticus

The present study was designed to evaluate the effect of supplementation with papaya seeds (PSM), fish testes powder (FTP), and 17α-methyltestosterone (MT) on the reproductive parameters, growth performance, digestive enzymes, and histology of Cyprinus carpio. In the present study, fries (2–3 days old) were acclimatized for 2 days and then equally distributed into one control and six treatment groups and fed with one control and six experimental diets for 30 days, followed by a control diet for 60 days in each group with triplicates. These diets included control (T0), different levels of 17α-methyltestosterone (T1: 60 mg/kg; T2: 70 mg/kg), papaya seed powder (T3: 6 g/kg; T4: 7 g/kg), and fish (tilapia) testes powder (T5: 70%; T6: 80%). The treatment groups receiving papaya seed meal (PSM) showed significant improvements in growth performance, with a significant increase in final body weight. The best zootechnical performances (PER, SGR, and CF) were observed in fish fed with papaya seed compared to the control group. Reproductive analysis showed significant variations between treatment groups, with a large number of female C. carpio observed in the control group. Fish treated with T4 increased the sex percentage in favor of male fish by achieving 90% male phenotype followed by T6 with 88% male. Diets based on papaya seeds and fish testes powder significantly reduced the reproductive performance by reducing GSI, which affected the gonadal histology. The results revealed a visible effect of 17 α-MT and PSM feeding on the gonad structure. There were significant elevations in protease enzyme activity in T6 compared to the control (p < 0.05), and the highest amylase activity was observed in T3. Natural resources are not only more cost-effective but also environmentally friendly and readily available; they are a superior choice over synthetic alternatives for controlling the prolific breeding of C. carpio.