In November 2017, a subreddit dedicated to ‘DeepFakes’ brought the work of machine-learning video face-swapping to widespread attention: the new ease of pornographic fakeswapping (focused primarily on celebrities, but also used more broadly to generate a type of revenge porn) became a content regulation topic of discussion on sites such as Pornhub and Reddit. Although the spaces dedicated to sharing these videos were gradually banned or moderated in early 2018, the essential project remains: a series of codebases shared on GitHub, actively situated for open source contributions. In this case study, we will examine the role of GitHub as a platform in the spread of DeepFakes, and interrogate the intersections of the open source ethos and Reddit's approach to moderation, ethics, and anonymity. Ultimately, we find that the DeepFakes project has intentionally spread to spaces with limited moderation, which has allowed the continued creation of non-consensual pornography.
In the DC Comics Universe, Harley Quinn and the Joker have been an iconic and problematic canonical couple, represented as everything from enviable “mad” lovers to abusive relationship cautionary tale. The couple made cinematic headlines in 2016 with the release of Suicide Squad. In this case study of the “mad love” canon/fanon ship (as embodied in recent works of fanfiction, shipper manifestos posted and shared through social media, and Tumblr discourse), I examine the progressive rhetoric and feminist elevation of Harley Quinn as a shield for the underlying toxicity of the Joker. Fandom’s discourse of “problematic faves” is important as it provides space for fans to love a text even while admitting its representational problems; however, in the case of Harley and the Joker, this discourse risks becoming an excuse for not subverting the toxic tropes of the idolized, abusive, yet still lovable, villain and his obsessive fangirl following.
Following a successful Kickstarter campaign, hybrid dating simulator and dungeon crawler Boyfriend Dungeon was released in August 2021 and was quickly met with significant fan critique. The game's advertised promise of cozy or “wholesome” play was contradicted by the presence of a content warning and an antagonist character exhibiting threatening, stalker-like behavior. The strength of the fan reactions caused the developers, Kitfox Games, to revise the content warning while simultaneously resisting requests to fundamentally remove or sideline the game's central conflict. Contextualizing this response through news coverage and Twitter discussion demonstrates the challenges of the fan-developer relationship, augmented by the disproportionate responsibilities and expectations placed on queer creators and the power dynamics of fan-supported indie development. This incident stands as a warning of the consequences of centering a constraining mode of “consent” and aesthetic demands of “coziness” on genres associated with relationships and queer romantic play.
In 2023, three major games introduced they/them pronouns into their character creation options: Baldur's Gate 3 (Larian Studios), Starfield (Bethesda); and Story of Seasons: A Wonderful Life (Marvelous). Each of these games comes from companies or series with a history of enforcing binary gender. Making such shifts to include both gender equity and same-sex romance sparked backlash, particularly at a moment when “woke” cultural production is under intense cultural scrutiny. By examining the responses to these three very different, but culturally significant, games, we contextualize the importance of meaningful gender and sexuality inclusivity in gaming given a history of reactionary movements in gaming culture (most notoriously Gamergate). Critically, all of these games became bestsellers, suggesting that while “go woke, go broke” might remain a rallying cry in small portions of gaming subculture, the move towards inclusivity is ultimately not harming the commercial success of these games.
This study focuses on the social media discourse of craftivism between March 2020 and December 2020, coinciding the COVID-19 lockdowns across the United States and the US Presidential Election. The timeframe under examination also includes some of the most extensively covered Black Lives Matter protests to date in the United States, thus requiring an intersectional lens and attention to whose crafts are circulated and lauded. These three deeply intertwined events raised tensions on social media platforms to new extremes, resulting in shifting moderation policies, and reflecting the increased significance of online communities to sustaining all relationships and movements. During this time, we argue that a fundamental shift in the discourse of craftivism has occurred, rejecting previous assumptions of ”gentleness” while demanding a public recentering of the domestic and ”femininized” labor. We contextualize this shift through three case studies: global memorial project COVID-19 quilt; political art project Tiny Pricks; and activist mask-making collective Auntie Sewing Squad. At the same time, this revision must be understood alongside collective failures of labor valuation and widespread economic crisis disproportionately impacting women (particularly women of color). In these cases, we see important intersectional resistance, even as white femininity in craft continues to be centered.